comprise a relatively small proportion of overall child protection
expenditure compared to tertiary services.180
127. First Nations children are significantly over-represented in the child
protection system. Between 2017 and 2021, the rate of Indigenous children
in out-of-home care increased from 51 per 1000, to 58 per 1000. 181
128. The Commission notes the extent to which children in care ‘crossover’ to
the youth justice system. The Australian Law Reform Commission found that
that ‘the links between these systems is so strong that child removal into
out-of-home care and juvenile detention could be considered as key drivers
of adult incarceration’.182 This is due in part to systemic issues related to outof-home care, such as ‘badly trained and poorly supported staff’ and a
‘readiness to call police to manage children’s behaviour’.183
129. The Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse
revealed the extent to which children have been maltreated while in the care
of institutions such as schools, recreational organisations, residential care,
youth detention and immigration detention. The Royal Commission
highlighted the ‘significant life-long impacts’ of sexual abuse, including ‘deep
and complex trauma’ that may affect all aspects of a victim/survivor’s life.184
The Commission welcomes the steps taken thus far to implement the
recommendations of the Royal Commission. In particular, the Commission
notes the National Redress Scheme,185 and the development and
endorsement by all governments of the National Principles for Child Safe
Organisations.186 The Commission urges continuous efforts to ensure the
full implementation of all the Royal Commission recommendations.
130. The Commission notes that, on the whole, there are significant gaps in the
implementation of children’s rights in law, and across policy, programs and
service delivery. The legal protections of children’s rights in Australia are not
comprehensive. Independent monitoring of children’s rights, including the
ability for children to make complaints, is limited. Overall, approaches to
children experiencing vulnerability are fragmented and are largely reactive
rather than preventative. The Commission has recommended the
development of a National Plan for Child Wellbeing, a dedicated Cabinet
Minister with overall responsibility for children’s rights, and a national
children’s data framework to improve and coordinate children’s policy and
service-delivery across government portfolios.187
Recommendation 29: The Australian Government increases prevention and
early intervention measures and responses to family violence that address
the distinct impacts of violence on children.
Recommendation 30: Governments resource prevention and early
intervention measures to address child abuse and neglect; and ensure
30