Australian Human Rights Commission
Submission to the UN Committee On The Elimination Of Racial Discrimination, 30 October 2017
likelihood of them receiving a custodial rather than non-custodial
sentence.105
The Special Rapporteur on the rights of Indigenous peoples has said
that mandatory sentencing laws need to be reviewed.106
The Commission has previously reported on several cases where
Indigenous people are in prolonged detention due to being considered
‘unfit to plead’, resulting in them being detained for a period longer than
the maximum sentence if they had been tried and found guilty. 107
92.
The Commission notes that the current inquiry by the ALRC into the
incarceration of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, reporting in
December 2017, will assist in identifying laws requiring amendment to reduce
Indigenous incarceration.108
93.
The Commission has advocated that justice targets be set to halve the gap in
rates of incarceration for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, as
compared with non-Indigenous people.109 The Senate Legal and Constitutional
Affairs Committee, and successive Social Justice Commissioners, have
recommended justice reinvestment strategies, which involve diverting and
reinvesting funds used for imprisonment to services that address underlying
causes of crime in communities with high rates of offending.110
94.
The Commission notes that the Australian Government recently expressed its
support for states and territories to implement a justice reinvestment
approach, but noted that it ‘cannot effectively fund justice reinvestment
projects because state and territory governments are solely responsible for
managing corrections systems in Australia’ and that ‘the success of justice
reinvestment … ultimately rests with the states and territories’.111
Recommendation 21: That all Australian governments commit to national
justice targets to reduce the rates of imprisonment of Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander adults and juveniles and that these targets be
introduced into the Closing the Gap Strategy.
(b)
Northern Territory Royal Commission
95.
The Commission is extremely concerned about the conditions of detention for
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander juveniles.
96.
The Commission commends the Australian Government’s establishment of a
Royal Commission into the Protection and Detention of Children in the
Northern Territory (NT Royal Commission).112 The inquiry is considering the
situation of all juveniles in detention and care and protection in the Northern
Territory. However, statistics show that 94% of the children and young people
in detention in the Northern Territory are Aboriginal.113 Furthermore, 89% of
children and young people in out-of-home care in the Northern Territory are
Aboriginal.114
97.
The NT Royal Commission released its interim report on 31 March 2017. The
interim findings noted that site visits to the current youth detention centres
20