Annual Report 2010-2011
recommended to the Government of Meghalaya to pay a sum of Rs. 5,00,000 to the next of
kin of the deceased and the amount of the 2,00,000 which had already been paid by the State
Government be adjusted.
4.47 The Government of Meghalaya has given its concurrence for paying the amount of
3,00,000 to the next of kin of the deceased. However, the proof of payment is awaited from the
State Government.
11.
Death of Bhuwan Dutt in Madhuban Police Station in Karnal District, Haryana
(Case No.1771/7/10/07-08-PCD)
4.48 The Commission received an intimation dated 3 September 2007 from the Assistant
Superintendent of Police in Karnal, Haryana about the death of one Bhuwan Dutt, aged 17
years, on 3 September 2007 who was in the custody of Police Station Madhuban in Karnal
District of Haryana. The deceased had committed suicide by burning himself. The deceased
was brought to Madhuban Police Station by one Sanjeev Kumar, a resident of Madhuban,
on 1 September 2007 in connection with a case Cr. No.115 dated 24 July 2007 u/s 302/301/34
IPC. Bhuwan Dutt set himself on fire by pouring petrol on the same day itself. He was then
admitted to PGIMS in Rohtak, Haryana on 2 September 2007 where he succumbed to his burn
injuries on 3 September 2007.
4.49 Taking cognizance of the matter, the Commission directed its Director General
(Investigation) to collect all the factual details which led to the death of Bhuwan Dutt and
accordingly submit a report. The post-mortem report stated that the deceased had died due
to burn injuries which were ante-mortem in nature and sufficient to cause death in ordinary
course of nature. The report submitted by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate claimed that as per the
recorded dying declaration of the deceased, it was amply clear he died on account of burning
himself and that no foul play was suspected in his death. As per the dying declaration recorded
by the Judicial Magistrate, the deceased had levelled serious allegations of torture against the
police and stated that one Inspector Pawan set him on fire.
4.50 The Commission took note of the serious lapse on the part of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate
who completely disregarded the allegations of torture by the police and the dying declaration
of the deceased recorded by the Judicial Magistrate. The deceased in his dying declaration
had mentioned that Inspector Pawan had set him on fire. The Commission stated that on the
basis of the dying declaration and the enquiry report submitted by the Judicial Magistrate,
it was convinced that the police personnel of Madhuban Police Station had committed one
of the most serious violations of human rights, which led to the death of Bhuwan Dutt. The
Commission directed to issue a show-cause notice to the Government of Haryana as to why
monetary relief should not be recommended to the next of kin of the deceased. The Commission
also recommended to conduct of a CB-CID enquiry in the matter.
4.51 In spite of several reminders issued by the Commission, no response was received from
the Government of Haryana on the show-cause notice issued by it. The Commission vide its
proceedings dated 28 October 2010, recommended to the State of Haryana to pay a sum of
28
NHRC