Annual Report 2010-2011
4.5
Pursuant to directions of the Commission, the State Government informed that in
an enquiry relating to Ramsingh Udasingh Ravana, the concerned enquiry Magistrate had
concluded that the deceased died enroute, while he was being taken to Bharuch Sub-Jail by
Maharashtra police as per the directions of the court. The deceased was not provided timely
medical care and the doctors of Talasari Dispensary in Maharashtra had too shown negligence
on their part.
4.6
Taking into consideration all the facts of the case, the Commission recommended to
the Chief Secretary, Government of Maharashtra, to pay a sum of 3,00,000 to the next of kin
of deceased Ramsingh Udasingh Ravana. On receiving the proof of payment made to the
next of kin of the deceased by the Government of Maharashtra, the case was closed by the
Commission.
2.
Suo motu Cognizance of Custodial Death in Central Jail No.6 of Tihar Jail, New Dehi
(Case No. 1138/4/4/08-09-JCD)
4.7
The Commission took suo motu cognizance of a news item which was published in the
Hindustan Times dated 7 July 2004 relating to the custodial death of one Zohara d/o Barat Ali,
aged 24 yrs, on 3 July 2004, while she was in Central Jail No.6 of Tihar Jail in New Delhi. The
deceased was in the jail since 2 February 1999 in connection with case FIR No.4/99, u/s 21/43,
61/83 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
4.8
The Commission directed its Director General (Investigation) to collect the requisite
reports within eight weeks. On consideration of the relevant reports received from the concerned
authority, the Commission observed that the deceased was ill and the related Medical Board
in order to provide prompt treatment had recommended her transfer to a better equipped
medical centre. It also noted that the patient was admitted on 21 June 2008 and the necessary
investigations were suggested on 22 June 2008. However, no investigation was carried out.
The deceased consequently died in Sadar Hospital on 6 July 2008 which testifies that no action
was taken by the jail authority for giving her proper medical treatment by referring her to a
better equipped medical centre till she died. On the other hand, if proper and timely medical
treatment had been provided, the life of the victim could have been saved. The Commission
thus concluded that the cause of death of the deceased was nothing short of sheer administrative
and medical negligence and recommended to the Government of NCT of Delhi to pay 3,00,000
as monetary relief to the next of kin of the deceased and also submit a compliance report along
with proof of payment.
4.9
The compliance report and proof of payment has since been received and the case
closed.
3.
Death of Convict Puran Singh in District Jail, Fatehgarh, Uttar Pradesh
(Case No.32064/24/2004-2005-CD)
4.10 The Commission received an intimation dated 24 September 2004 from the Senior
Superintendent of Police in Fatehgarh about the death of a prisoner, Puran Singh. He was
undergoing life imprisonment in Fategarh District Jail. While in prison, it was detected that
20
NHRC