Over two dozen constructive letters were sent
to the Prime Minister, Ministers, and officials
coordinating the Government’s response:
• Expressing our willingness to help the
Government ensure its response to COVID-19 is
fair, effective and proportionate.
• Seeking assurance and offering support in
respect of protecting disabled people (24% of
our population) during Alert Level 4.
• Urging health officials to ensure access to
healthcare for people with terminal and acute
conditions were safeguarded.
• Calling for decisions on the allocation of
resources and treatment to be transparent,
evidence-based, and non-discriminatory.2
• Raising concerns in the Chief Commissioner’s
role as Chair of the Central National Preventive
Mechanism about the rights of people in
detention, including people held in prisons,
police cells, Oranga Tamariki residences,
intellectual disability units, aged care facilities,
and temporary places of detention for
quarantine purposes during the response to
the pandemic.3
• Advocating to avoid discriminatory prioritisation
of medical assistance.
As details emerged about community workers
struggling to access personal protective
equipment (PPE) to visit people with high needs
and vulnerabilities we urged officials to urgently
make PPE available to community-based carers.
Our concerns were supported by the findings
of the Auditor-General who found there were
mixed messages about PPE guidance, that some
emergency plans were out of date, that there
was a lack of integration between various parts
of the health and disability system, and that
DHBs did not have links to all providers.4 We also
encouraged women to seek help immediately if
they found themselves in an abusive situation
during the COVID-19 isolation5 and people to
stand up to racism during the crisis.6
Commissioners and staff strengthened
connections with iwi and the most marginalised
communities to ensure their views were reflected
in decision making. We set up a central repository
for COVID-19 and human rights information to
ensure groups had access to the right information
and were able to report issues and concerns.7 Our
enquiries and complaints function saw a dramatic
increase in demand with over 300 enquiries and
complaints related to COVID-19 between January
and the start of May 2020.
When necessary, we held decision-makers to
account.8 We established the Kaiwhakatara
Accountability Advisory Group to help us to
ensure a clear rights-based message was
reaching Government. The members of this
group are Andrew Butler, Associate Professor
Dr Claire Charters, Dr Carwyn Jones, Frances
Joychild QC, Richard Leung, Professor Margaret
Mutu, Professor Gail Pacheco, Dr Teuila Percival,
Bernadette Ingham and Julia Amua Whaipooti.9
https://www.hrc.co.nz/news/access-healthcare-terminal-and-acute-patients-must-be-safeguarded/
https://www.hrc.co.nz/news/concerns-about-rights-people-detention-during-response-covid-19/
4
https://www.hrc.co.nz/news/auditor-general-review-findings-failings-ppe-distribution-no-surprise-says-disability-rightscommissioner/
5
https://covid19.hrc.co.nz/unsafe_at_home_reach_out_for_help_says_women_s_rights_commissioner
6
https://covid19.hrc.co.nz/meng_foon_covid_19_coronavirus_fear_no_excuse_for_racism
7
https://covid19.hrc.co.nz/your-rights
8
https://www.hrc.co.nz/news/letter-all-new-zealanders-commissioners-human-rights-commission-our-responsecovid-19/
9
https://covid19.hrc.co.nz/about
2
3
17