The principle of the best interests of the child potentially could conflict with parental rights to
choose education for their children.431 Although parents have freedom over their choice of
education for their children, this guarantee is not absolute.
Due to the “best interests”
principle and the requirement for basic levels of education to be compulsory and free, the
State must ensure that parents’ choices do not exclude children from enjoying their right to
education. Thus, freedom of choice must be subject to the obligation to promote the best
interests of the child, including ensuring a proper quality of education and the meeting of
minimum education standards.432 In the case of a conflict between parental choice and the
best interests of the child, the latter prevail. This is because the rationale behind parental
choice is not to legitimise their denial of their children’s right to education; rather, choice
prevents State monopoly over education and protects pluralism.433
States must respect the freedom of individuals to provide religious instruction in schools
established by members of that religion.434 States also have an obligation to respect the right
of members of a particular language group to establish a school and to use their language in
that school.435 Of course, education in such schools must be directed to the dual aims of
education and must conform to minimum educational standards.
431
See term of reference (i) for a discussion on the best interests of the child.
See CRC, articles 3 and 29(2); ICESCR article 13(3); CESCR General Comment No. 13: The right
to education E/C.12/1999/10 8 December 1999 at para 6(c).
433
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the right to education E/CN.4/2003/9 21 January 2003 at
para 17.
434
ICESCR, article 13(3); ICCPR, article 18(4); CADE, article 5(1)(b). See term of reference (viii) for
a discussion of the obligation of States to respect religious practices within educational institutions.
435
CADE, article 5(1)(c). See term of reference (viii) for a discussion of the obligation of States to
respect cultural practices within educational institutions.
432
137