(iii)
The length of time for which a person can be deprived of their liberty under
international law without being charged
• Anyone arrested or detained for any reason, including in relation to a terrorist offence, has
the right to be brought promptly (without delay) before a judicial officer to challenge the
legality of their detention.
• All persons arrested or detained on a criminal charge are entitled to a trial within a
reasonable period.
• Even where detention is lawful and not arbitrary at inception, it can become arbitrary if the
length of detention is not necessary and proportional to the circumstances. There should be
an opportunity for regular judicial review of the continuing necessity for detention.
• It is recognised that terrorist offences are serious offences and may present particular
security concerns. The investigation of these offences may also take longer because of
their complexity and possible international component. All of these factors must be
weighed by a judicial authority when making a decision as to the necessity to detain and
the appropriate limits on the length of detention.
DISCUSSION
Article 9(4) of the ICCPR provides that anyone deprived of liberty by arrest or detention shall
be entitled to take proceedings before a court so that the court may decide without delay on
the lawfulness of the detention and order release if the detention is not lawful. Accordingly,
all persons who have been deprived of their liberty are, regardless of the reasons, entitled to a
right to have the detention reviewed in a court without delay. It has been commented that the
true significance of this right comes to light in the case of preventive cases of deprivation of
liberty
(commonly called “administrative detention”) beyond that required for criminal
justice (as remand proceedings are available in respect of pre-trial detention). As discussed
39