Shining Light into Dark Corners
1
Submission of report
Reports are submitted by stakeholders (including national
reports, parallel reports from the NGOs, and independent
opinions of the National Human Rights Commission etc.)
6
2
Implement and
follow-up
List of Issues
Each government
institution develops
its own implement,
management, and
evaluation practices
The National
Report Review
System
5
International Review
Committee raises a list
of issues
December 10, 2020 – Commissioner of National Human Rights Commission Yeh Ta-hua released Independent Opinion on the Third
National Report on the ICCPR and ICESCR on behalf of the National Human Rights Commission.
3
Concluding
observations and
Response to the
recommendations
list of issues
The International Review
Committee published
concluding observations and
recommendations
Responses to the list
of issues are given by
government agencies
or by the NGOs on a
parallel basis
4
Review of National Report
International review meetings are
convened
Article 5 of the Implementation Act (draft) stipulates
to submit reports explaining the measures taken
that "the National Human Rights Commission shall
and the progresses made with respect to various
develop specific measures against torture," which
conventions to relevant institutions of the United
empowers the National Human Rights Commission
Nations, including: UN Human Rights Committee
with more important duties.
(Ar ticle 40 of ICCPR), UN Economic and
Social Council (Articles 16 and 17 of ICESCR),
52
Establishment of National Reporting System and
Invitation of International Review Committee to
Taiwan
Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination
It has been stipulated in UN human rights
CRC), and Committee on the Rights of Persons with
conventions that all States Parties are obligated
Disabilities (Article 35 of CRPD).
against Women (Article 18 of CEDAW), UN
Committee on the Rights of the Child (Article 44 of
How should Taiwan fulfill the two Covenants
(4) World-renowned human rights expert/scholar.
when it is not a member of the United Nations?
(5) Previous involvement in reviewing human rights
Taiwan adopted a distinctive and exclusive
report of other countries.
international review system when making its
first national report of the two Covenants. In
Via this system, government agencies and non-
2013, international human rights experts were
governmental organizations can engage in
invited to Taiwan to review the national report,
constructive dialogues and exchanges with
which followed the same procedures as UN;
international human rights experts to enable Taiwan
these experts then gave advice on the current
to voluntarily adhere to and implement core human
state of human rights in Taiwan, and published
rights convention practices. This approach is well-
concluding observations and recommendations.
recognized and accepted by the international
community.
Members of the International Review
Committee had to qualify for one of the
following:
After the National Human Rights Commission
(1) Current or former member of a human rights-
“Independent Opinion on the Third National Report
related core committee under the United
on the ICCPR and ICESCR” on December 10,
Nations.
2020, and submitted the report to the International
(2) Current or former member of a non-government
organization under the United Nations.
was founded, the commission presented the
Review Committee for review. The NHRC also
plans to present “Independent Opinion of the
(3) Current or former special rapporteur for a core
National Human Rights Commission on the Second
human rights-related convention of the United
National Report on the Convention on the CRPD”
Nations.
in 2021.
53