First Nations Consultations For the Australian Human Rights Commission
5 Barriers and Enablers
5.1 Decision Making
First Nations voices must be central in all decision-making processes. Participants highlighted the
importance of genuine consultation and representation in developing policies and programs that
affect First Nations communities. Establishing First Nations advisory bodies at local, regional, and
national levels is crucial to ensure that First Nations perspectives are integral to policy
development and implementation. These bodies should have real decision-making power and not
merely serve as advisory panels.
The ongoing failure of successive, State, Territory and Commonwealth governments to engage in
shared decision making with First Nations communities and Aboriginal Community Controlled
Organisations is a major contributing factor to ongoing systemic racism, inequalities and failure to
improve health outcomes nationally. The National Anti-Racism Framework needs to be supported
by commitments to strengthen relevant State and Commonwealth legislation that would ensure
the greater right to self-determination of First Nations people.
Decision making needs related to the development, implementation and monitoring of the
National Anti-Racism Framework need to be evidence-based and aligned to the principles of IDS
and IDG. This will also require the development of new and improved reporting and monitoring
tools that are strengths-based and better align with First Nations ways of knowing, being and
doing.
5.2 Funding
Funding was discussed across multiple contexts throughout the consultations. Fundamentally,
participants stated that commitment to equitable and transparent funding models are needed.
Participants spoke of the frustration of communities being constantly held to the whim of the
‘money managers’ with little to no oversight of the way in which funding was allocated or
distributed. A male Elder in Mparntwe spoke of funding cycles being like government
commitments in the way that they have a very short lived ‘used by date’. He spoke to the
impossibilities of progress under this short-sighted model whilst ‘Colonisation is enduring and
everlasting and continues to affect mob everyday’.
Sustainable funding is critical for the success of anti-racism initiatives (Tucker et al., 2023).
Participants called for increased and targeted funding for programs that address the
specific needs of First Nations communities. Resources should be allocated to First
Nations-led initiatives, ensuring that funding is controlled by First Nations organisations
rather than non-First Nations entities. This approach ensures that resources are
directed in a manner that truly reflects and addresses the priorities of the
community.
The underfunding of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services
is a major barrier to addressing the systemic racism experiences
by First Nations people. This historical underfunding is a major
reason why First Nations people don’t seek legal recourse for
An Anti-Racism Framework: Voices of First Nations Peoples
Page 51