Requiring surgical requirements for gender recognition by the court becomes a subject of
criticism for making gender recognition difficult462) because they are required for legal
reasons, even though not medically needed. The sex of others is not recognized in the form
of external genitalia in social life, and genital reconstruction surgery is often not performed
or cannot be performed depending on economic (cost) or medical factors (unnecessary and
risky). Nevertheless, requesting this is contrary to the purpose of medical ethics of
maintaining the highest attainable level of health,463) and is an unreasonable violation of the
constitutional right not to be physically harmed.464) In this respect, Sweden, which had
requested the removal of fertility as a requirement for gender recognition until 2013, has
conceded to a claim for damages from the state.465)
C) Right to Gender Recognition of Transgenders
At its 19th session on Jun. 17, 2011, the UN Human Rights Council adopted its first
resolution focusing on human rights violations based on sexual orientation and gender
identity,466) and, at its 27th session on Sep. 27, 2014, it again adopted a new resolution on the
prohibition of discrimination and violence based on sexual orientation and gender identity.467)
In accordance with this resolution, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights submitted
‘Discriminatory Laws and Practices and Acts of Violence Against Individuals Based on
Their Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity’ report in 2011 and 2015, respectively, and the
report recommended that each state issue legal identity documents that reflect the preferred
gender upon application and eliminate harsh requirements, such as the removal of fertility
and compulsory medical care.468)
462) According to the NHRCK’s 2020 ‘Survey on Hate and Discrimination Against Transgenders,’ only 8.0% (47 people)
of 591 respondents completed legal gender recognition. 86.0% (508 people) had never attempted gender
recognition, and the reasons for this were ‘due to the cost of medical treatment related to gender change’ (58.9%),
‘due to complicated legal procedures’ (40.0%), and ‘due to the health burden caused by medical treatments related
to gender change” (29.5%).
463) Han, Ga-ram, Requirements and Issues of Gender Recognition of Transgenders, 1st Colloquium of the Korean
Society of Law and Policy on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI), Jun. 29, 2013.
464) NHRCK Human Rights Status Survey, Survey on the Status of Transgender Hatred and Discrimination, 2020.
465) TGEU, Sweden announces to pay compensation to trans people. Mar. 28, 2017.
466) UN Human Rights Council, Human rights, sexual orientation and gender identity, Jul. 14, 2011 (UN Doc. A/HRC/
RES/17/19)
467) Human Rights Council, Human rights, sexual orientation and gender identity, 2014. 9. 24.(UN Doc. A/HRC/27/
L.27/Rev.1)
194
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents