PASTOR RAYMOND KOH 148.3. The telephone call logs on the morning of 12.5.2018 of Sgt Shamzaini, before he met Norhaya�, showed that he had contacted Aizat, a member of Perlis Hope before he had even spoken to Pharid. This shows that even before he met Norhaya�, Sgt Shamzaini knew that she was somehow connected with Perlis Hope and that was the reason he had contacted Aizat before speaking to Pharid. Sgt Shamzaini wanted Aizat to pass him Norhaya�'s number. 148.4. When he could not get Norhaya�'s number from Pharid, he tried calling both Pharid and Aizat again that night. It was only a�er he had failed to get Norhaya�’s telephone number, that he knocked on the door of her house a�er 10:00 p.m. that evening. 148.5. This also contradicts Sgt Shamzaini’s evidence that he went to Pharid Auto to have his car �nted. This was clearly an excuse to speak to Pharid and to get Norhaya�'s telephone number. If he had genuinely wanted to get his car �nted he would not have called Aizat before he called Pharid, and he would not have asked Pharid for Norhaya�' s number. 148.6. Firstly, it is incongruous that a policeman from the Special Branch in Kangar, Perlis would want to meet with the wife of a man whose disappearance was the subject of an ongoing police inves�ga�on and a Public Inquiry, in which the ac�ons of the Special Branch officers, both in Kangar, Perlis and in Bukit Aman, Kuala Lumpur were under scru�ny. Sgt Shamzaini surely cannot seriously contend that he did not know of Norhaya�'s iden�ty because from the contradic�ons outlined above the Panel can safely infer that he knew whom he was talking to before he met Norhaya�. 148.7. Secondly, and flowing from the first incongruence, it is the admi�ed evidence of Sgt Shamzaini that the mee�ng on the night of 12 May 2018 lasted for two (2) hours, during which �me Norhaya� confronted him with a series of accusa�ons on the conduct of the police in the disappearance of her husband. The tenancy of the premises occupied by Pharid was not discussed at all except in a very peripheral way. If Sgt Shamzaini is to be believed, it means that he spent two (2) hours listening to Norhaya�'s accusa�ons and laments about the role of the police in the abduc�on of her husband and that he finally le� a�er she threatened to lodge a police report against him accusing him of being part of her husband's disappearance! 50