Australian Human Rights Commission
Australia and the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
Discrimination (ICERD), Shadow report to the CERD Committee – 8 July 2010
Recommendation 46: That the Australian Government implement the remaining
recommendations of A last resort? in order to address ongoing concerns
about the situation of children under Australia’s immigration detention
system. 141
8.6
Detention and offshore processing on Christmas Island
158.
The Commission has raised significant concerns about the mandatory
detention of asylum seekers on Christmas Island, a remote territory of
Australia in the Indian Ocean. As of 26 March 2010, there were 2068 people
in immigration detention on Christmas Island, including 163 children. 142 The
remote location and small size of the island limit detainees’ access to
appropriate services and support networks, and the location makes their
detention arrangements less visible and transparent to the Australian public.
159.
The Commission has also raised concerns about the excision regime, under
which asylum seekers who arrive in excised offshore places such as
Christmas Island are barred from the refugee status determination system
that applies under the Migration Act. 143 Instead, they go through a nonstatutory refugee status assessment process governed by policy guidelines.
160.
The Commission’s concerns are set out in full in its 2009 report, Immigration
detention and offshore processing on Christmas Island. 144 This report has
been submitted to the Committee.
Recommendation 47: That the Australian Government cease the practice of
holding people in immigration detention on Christmas Island, and repeal the
provisions of the Migration Act relating to excised offshore places. 145
8.7
The suspension of processing of some asylum claims
161.
On 9 April 2010, the Australian Government announced that it was
suspending processing of new refugee claims by asylum seekers from Sri
Lanka and Afghanistan. 146 The suspension came into effect on the same day.
It will impact any asylum seeker from Sri Lanka or Afghanistan who is
intercepted at sea or who arrives in an excised offshore place (including
Christmas Island) on or after that date, and any asylum seeker from Sri
Lanka or Afghanistan who applies for refugee status on the Australian
mainland on or after that date. 147
162.
Asylum seekers from Sri Lanka or Afghanistan who arrive by boat on or after
9 April 2010 will be subjected to mandatory immigration detention for the
duration of the suspension. The Australian Government has indicated that it
will review the suspension in three months time in the case of asylum
seekers from Sri Lanka, and in six months time in the case of asylum seekers
from Afghanistan. However, there is no guarantee that the suspension will be
lifted at those reviews.
163.
The Commission has expressed serious concerns about the suspension
decision. 148 In particular, the Commission is concerned that it could lead to
43