Limited control of immediate environment
In several of the health and disability units the light switches and blinds for
each room could only be controlled from the outside. In the At Risk unit at
Christchurch men’s prison light switches were similarly outside the cell, and
blue lights stayed on all night. At Rolleston prison, lights in ‘Pound’ units
were controlled from the outside only. This was also the case at Auckland
prison and Auckland South’s At Risk units, though at Auckland South we
were told that prisoners could use the call bell and ask for lights to be turned
on or off at any time they wanted.
Poor temperature control
Temperature control was poor in a number of the institutions visited. For
example, the de-escalation rooms at Te Whare Ahuru (Hutt Valley DHB) were
too hot, whereas the air conditioning in one of the rooms in the Secure Care
Unit at the Youth Justice residence was set on too low a temperature on the
day of our visit, making the room very cold. The custody suite at Wellington
police station, which was located underground, tended, according to officers
working there, to get very cold in winter and very hot in summer. This was
the case despite there being a forced air ducting system in place with sensors
designed to keep temperatures within an appropriate range
Lack of privacy
Most high-risk cells in the facilities visited were continuously monitored by
close-circuit cameras which covered the entire cell/room area, including
the toilet, affording detainees no privacy. Examples include the ARU cells in
Christchurch Men’s and Christchurch Women’s, and the Police custody suite
in Wellington.
Lack of individual autonomy and over-reliance on the goodwill and availability
of staff in the provision of basic necessities
Where these were not available in their room, access to a number of basic
provisions (discussed above) was dependent on the goodwill of staff/officers/
nurses. Some examples include: providing drinking water to prisoners, patients
and young people who did not have access to it inside their cell/room ;
responding to the hand signals of a distressed child in a Secure Care cell (as the
call bell didn’t work); escorting a patient to the toilet as their seclusion room/
segregation cell is not equipped with one (as was the case in seclusion room in
many health and disability units and prison ‘soft’ and ‘round’ cells); providing
ARU prisoners with toilet paper “as needed” (Auckland Men’s); relying on prison
staff to override the mechanism which only allowed for 10 or 15 or, in one
46