Human Rights And Statelessness
I N P E N I N S U L AR M AL AYS I A
It is important to note that personal and citizenship identity is multifaceted,
and that individuals may fall under multiple categories. For example, a
child born in Bangladesh to a Malaysian mother and Bangladeshi father out
of wedlock could be analysed under categories 4, 5, and 6 for the purposes
of this study – but an interview with them or their guardian would ‘count’
as a single addition to the number of participants involved in the study.
Desk review
The desk review was conducted over a diverse range of knowledge,
including government data, academic journals, think tank and policy
reports, media articles, social media, and other relevant national
and foreign materials/ research on statelessness in Malaysia. It was
conducted in both English and Bahasa Malaysia. We found a total of 220
source materials on statelessness, with the breakdown listed in Table 2.
Table 2: Breakdown of desk review according to source type
Source type
Number
Media articles
74
Government responses
70
Academic articles (journals, books)
33
NGO reports
10
Legal provisions
33
Total
220
In-depth interviews
We conducted 89 interviews over four months, between September 2021
and December 2021. Interviews were conducted by authors M.N., N.F.,
and S.T. The target number was 80 interviews: 60 stateless individuals,
15 CSO members, and five government agency representatives. We ended
up exceeding our interview target by 11.25%. Interviews were done with
participants from all across Peninsular Malaysia – with the modes of
interview being Zoom or phone (most common) and in-person. The map
displaying the geographical spread of participants can be found in Figure
3. Table 3 summarises the number of interviews conducted for each of
the categories and subcategories of participants.
12