Australian Human Rights Commission
Respect at Uni Interim Report
December 2024
scared walking around campus and do not feel comfortable nor safe at
times. 75
My younger brother currently ‘attends’ University. I say ‘attends’ loosely,
because in reality, he is afraid to step foot on campus. He is afraid to be
confronted or targeted. He is afraid to be proud of his heritage. He is
afraid that, because he believes in the Jewish right to self-determination
and safety in the Jewish ancestral homeland, we will be ostracised,
doxxed, harassed or attacked. 76
Ms Segal AO also submitted:
The Jewish students are traumatised and feel isolated and unsafe. They
are not participating as they should in university life. They have been told
by their university administration to stay home for their own safety. 77
In initial Commission consultations, Jewish students expressed a nuanced view of
the balance between safety and protest, acknowledging that:
…putting a tent on a university lawn is not antisemitic, advocating for
Palestine is not antisemitic. But there are moments that crossed the line
where you see demonisation and social exclusion.
In Commission consultations, concerns were raised about postering linked to
neo-Nazi groups and other extremist actors on campus.
The Inquiry reported on a range of actions taken by universities to respond to
protests and provide a safe, inclusive environment and noted that some
responses were more effective than others. The large majority of submissions to
the Inquiry described the responses as inadequate. Similarly, Jewish students
told the Commission in initial consultations that responses did not adequately
address their concerns.
In its initial consultations, the Commission also heard about the experiences of
Palestinian students and students of other backgrounds feeling unsafe during
the protests and encampments. For instance, the Commission heard of a
Palestinian student who was confronted and intimidated on campus.
Evidence from TEQSA to the Inquiry notes that the number of complaints has
slowed since June 2024, ‘consistent with protest camps closing down. And many
universities commencing the mid-year break.’ 78 Regardless, consultations indicate
that feelings of safety and support need to be fostered across the university
community.
47