84. Solitary confinement and lockdowns continue to be used in youth justice
centres. In the Western Australian Banksia Hill detention centre, extensive
‘rolling’ lockdowns in early 2022 led to one teenage boy being locked in his
cell on more than 25 separate occasions for up to 20 hours a day. The
Western Australia Supreme Court ruled that this breached the Young
Offenders Act 1994 (WA).95 The Court found that the repeated use of
lockdowns was primarily caused by ‘chronic staff shortages’.96 The Western
Australia Inspector for Custodial Services had previously formed a view that
conditions in Banksia Hill were potentially ‘cruel, inhuman and degrading’
and operated like ‘an adult prison’.97
85. In July 2022, the Tasmanian Ashley Youth Detention Centre instituted a twoweek lockdown, where detainees were locked in their rooms and only let
out on a rotational 40-minute basis. This was also attributed to staffing
shortages.98 Currently, Tasmania's Commission of Inquiry into Government
Responses into Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Settings is also inquiring
into sexual abuse at the Ashley Youth Detention Centre.99
86. The evidence indicates that children entering youth detention have
significant pre-existing vulnerabilities, including neurological disabilities,
trauma and mental health issues.100 In detention they are not receiving the
specialist therapies and treatment they need. These pre-existing issues are
exacerbated by the experience of incarceration, which leads to behaviours
such as suicide attempts and self-harm. The Commission is concerned about
the failure to provide treatment for pre-existing conditions; the failure to
ensure detention does not further traumatize children; and the failure to
provide qualified acute mental health treatment for suicidality and self-harm
to ensure safety and promote recovery.
87. The Commission urges the Australian Government to raise the minimum
age of criminal responsibility to at least 14 years, in line with international
standards.101 In August 2020, the ACT became the first jurisdiction in
Australia to support raising the age of criminal responsibility from ten to 14
years. In a November 2021 meeting, state Attorneys-General supported the
development of a proposal to increase the minimum age of criminal
responsibility from ten to 12 years.102 However this has not been enacted in
any of the state jurisdictions.
88. Article 37(b) of Convention on the Rights of the Child states that children
should only be deprived of liberty as a last resort and for the shortest
appropriate period of time. However, diversion is underutilised for a variety
of reasons, including limits to who can access the programs, insufficient
staffing allocated to diversion, and lack of sufficient appropriately funded
and culturally appropriate programs.103 The Northern Territory Royal
Commission found that First Nations children and young people are less
20