Australian Human Rights Commission
Report title October 2022
CERD Committee found that they have a ‘racially discriminatory impact on
the [First Nations] rate of incarceration’.81
71. The Commission reiterates its concern that funding for National Aboriginal
and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services is insufficient to meet the legal
needs of First Nations communities.82 It emphasises the importance of selfdetermined, culturally safe legal services as a means of protecting against
arbitrary arrest and cruel treatment in the criminal justice system, and
realising the right to a fair trial for First Nations people.
72. More must be done to work meaningfully with First Nations communities to
implement substantial and ongoing solutions. The Commission has called on
Australian governments to invest further in diversionary programs for
adults, young people and children. Diversionary programs should be
designed to effectively address the causes of offending. They should be used
to divert people from further interaction with the criminal justice system in
circumstances where sentencing is unlikely to be successful in preventing
further offending. Resourcing should be available to communities to address
the key drivers of criminal behaviour before offending occurs. Examples of
successful justice reinvestment programs can be seen around the country.83
73. Governments should also prioritise prison and detention-based
rehabilitative programs and invest in creating pathways out of the criminal
justice system, such as the provision of throughcare programs and postrelease accommodation.
74. There is evidence that institutional racism within the criminal justice system
contributes to high rates of imprisonment and deaths in custody. First
Nations peoples experience unequal outcomes in key areas. For example,
the Australian Law Reform Commission found that First Nations people are
less likely to receive community-based sentences than non-Indigenous
offenders, and as a result, may be more likely to be imprisoned for the same
offence.84 Death inquests point to concerning instances of racism within the
criminal justice system. The ongoing Northern Territory inquest into the
police shooting death of Kumanjayi Walker has revealed racist attitudes
within the Northern Territory police force.85 When addressing the causes of
Aboriginal woman Ms Dhu’s death in 2016, the Western Australia Coroner
found that while the individual officers were not consciously motivated by
racism, ‘it would be naïve to deny the existence of societal patterns that lead
to assumptions being formed in relation to Aboriginal persons’.86
75. The Commission endorses the goal of the National Partnership Agreement –
as agreed to by all governments in Australia – to ‘identify and call out
institutional racism, discrimination and unconscious bias’ and to ‘undertake
17