FROM BONDAGE TO FREEDOM
83
The Protocol contains a number of provisions aimed at preventing
trafficking - all of which are phrased in UN’s best, programmatic, nonobligatory style207. Despite the attention given to the issue, there is no
reference to the acknowledged root causes of trafficking. Also, it fails to
take into account the existence of such preventive measures, which are
discriminatory against women and other groups and restrain freedom of
movement. A non-discrimination clause in the saving provisions cannot
rectify this anomaly.
On the overall analysis of the Protocol it is brought to the fore that
the Protocol does not break new grounds in terms of human rights
protection and generally espouses a crime-control approach. But at the
same time it represents a significant step forward in the fight against
trafficking and related exploitation and acts as a meeting ground for
different viewpoints and approaches on the issue. The importance given
to State Cooperation in preventing and combating trafficking would go a
long way in fighting against the evil of trafficking in persons with the
legal regime in place. What is required is moral commitment on the part
of State Parties to see to effective implementation of the Protocol.
Protocol Against the Smuggling of Migrants by Land, Sea and Air,
supplementing the United Nations Convention Against Transnational
Organized Crime (Smuggling of Migrants Protocol)
D. Background / Origin
The Government of Austria presented the initial proposal for a legal
instrument to deal with the smuggling of migrants to the Commission on
Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice208. At the same time, the Italian
Government, in an attempt to deal with the growing problem of migrant
smuggling from Albania, approached the International Maritime
Organization (IMO) with a proposal for the issuance of directives
regarding trafficking of migrants by sea. Italy subsequently decided to
join forces with the Austrians in pushing for the development of a legal
instrument against migrant smuggling within the context of the
Commission’s work against transnational organized crime.209
208
Letter from the Austraian Permanent Representative to the United Nations to the UN SecretaryGeneral dated 16 Sep 1997 accompanying the Draft International Convention against the
Smuggling and Illegal Migrants, UN Doc. A/52/357 (1997).
209
Dimitri V. Lassis, The United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime
and its Three Protocols: Development and Outlook (unpublished), p 15.