FROM BONDAGE TO FREEDOM
81
to include what have recently been defined as worst forms of child labour
has not been taken up in the Protocol.205
Furthermore, the definition of trafficking as given in the Protocol
fails to distinguish clearly between a trafficked person and a smuggled
migrant thereby leading many trafficked persons to be treated as
smuggled migrants and being denied special protection and assistance
as laid down in the Protocol.
Protection of Trafficked Persons
The protection provisions in Part II of the Protocol are worded in
optional tone. They are restrictive and not in accordance with international
human rights law, which clearly provides that, victims of human rights
violation such as trafficking should be provided with access to adequate
and appropriate remedies. At a minimum, States Parties should be obliged
to provide information to trafficking victims on the possibility of obtaining
remedies, including compensation for trafficking and other criminal acts
to which they have been subjected.
The Protocol also, fails to protect the trafficked person from
prosecution for status-related offences such as illegal migration, working
without proper documentation and prostitution.
An earlier draft provision on the seizure, confiscation and disposal
of gains from trafficking was deleted following agreements that the
relevant article of the Convention would apply mutatis mutandis.
However, essence of the provision was lost in this move and States Parties
will now not be required to use the proceeds from seizure and confiscation
to fund assistance and compensation for victims of trafficking.
Further, the weakness of the Protocol’s protection provisions is likely
to undermine its effectiveness as a law enforcement instrument. The
identification and prosecution of traffickers rely heavily on the cooperation
of trafficked persons and without providing effective protection to the
victims of trafficking there cannot be effective prosecution as the fear of
backlash from traffickers would keep the victims from giving evidence
in the court.
Status and Repatriation
The provisions on determination of status of the victims of