Empowering National Human Rights Institutions to Advance
Rights-Based Climate Action
13
The Needs Assessment
2. and Gap Analysis
Despite the recognised role of NHRIs in relation to monitoring and advising the government
in the context of CCMA, most of the NHRIs face significant challenges in effectively
monitoring related aspects, especially when collaborating with other national and
international actors. In many countries, comprehensive systems to track all human rights
obligations and recommendations in the context of CCMA are lacking.57 NHRIs encounter
obstacles such as limited capacity, access, security, resources, and political will from national
authorities. Moreover, NHRIs often operate in isolation, lacking a coordinated approach
to monitoring and investigating the human rights impacts of CCMA projects and policies,
particularly in relation to human mobility.
NHRIs face significant challenges in handling displacement caused by disasters, which
increases their already heavy workloads. According to the UN Special Rapporteur on the
Rights of Internally Displaced Persons, NHRIs express concerns about their ability to monitor
human rights during emergencies and emphasise the need for more funding, capacity,
and staffing to effectively address these issues.58 Many NHRIs struggle with inadequate
resources, limiting their ability to assist internally displaced persons (IDPs). While some NHRIs
have developed the capacity to respond to displacement, others must quickly adapt to these
new challenges, requiring long-term staffing solutions. Despite these difficulties, NHRIs are
well-positioned to work with governments, civil society, and international partners to prevent
displacement and support solutions for IDPs.59
This Needs Assessment and Gap Analysis aims to identify challenges faced by NHRIs in
South Asia regarding their monitoring and advisory roles in CCMA initiatives.60 For this
purpose, CCMA refers to two complementary approaches to addressing the impacts of
climate change – mitigation and adaptation. Climate change mitigation refers to efforts to
reduce or prevent the emission of greenhouse gases to limit the severity of climate change,
while climate change adaptation involves adjusting systems and practices to minimise
Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights Institutions, ‘Request for Proposals and TOR to Conduct the Needs Assessment and Gap
Analysis in Relation to CCMA’ (2023).
57
Human Rights Council, ‘Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Rights of IDPs Re: Internal Displacement and the Role of NHRIs (A/
HRC/41/40)’ (2019) <https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/g19/109/19/pdf/g1910919.pdf>.
58
59
Ibid.
60
Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights Institutions (n 58).