a much advanced and developed countries as compared to the third world
countries. Do the presenters agree with the statement?
Ms. Verma responded that there are challenges but there are technical
cooperation and commitment to review laws and policies in ensuring
adequate capacity as well as financial resources for the training of staffs.
However, there are creative ways while of course pushing for more budget
allocation. Ms. Verma stated her honest view was that there is no
government as far as she was concerned that prioritises or allocates a budget
to prison reform higher than it does to for example, for defence.
Ms. Verma reiterated that many of the Mandela Rules and Bangkok Rules do
not require additional resources for their implementation in totality. While
it would be an easier task for the government to specifically allocate more
budget but at the end of the day, it all comes down to political will and
commitment to ensure the implementation of those basic guidelines. She
thinks that it does not require money.68
Mr. Tanaka stated that the cooperation such as public-private partnership
has shown a beneficial improvement in fostering rehabilitation and social
integration of offenders. The concept of partnership between public-private
sectors is less common than the application of non-custodial inmates, but he
thinks that the cooperation of State authorities with private corporations
could enhance the management of prisons and may become an option to the
prison reform efforts.
IX.
Ms. Lynn from Women’s Prison, Kajang, Selangor, Malaysia shared her
experience regarding the implementation of Mandela Rules in Malaysian
prisons. Previously, her prison in Kajang for example provides only
mattress but currently prisoners are given double-decker bed and it is
slowly expanding to other prisons. Her prison managed to get a dental chair
through the collaborative initiative of the institution and sponsorship from
ICRC.
Dato’ Narander Singh in his response to the sharing added that Human Rights
Watch should be included in the partnership with prison institution as they
will holding the government accountable for the management of prisoners
and their rights.
X.
Ms. Shanta Orian, Malaysian Care asked whether there is any material or
links on best practices for the management of mental health of prisoners
and prison staffs for sharing since there are discussions about suicide
68
Human rights commitment requires political will and that is the reason for the existence of OHCHR and NHRIs
like SUHAKAM in Malaysia to support and to tell the State about its responsibility to fulfill human rights of the
people. OHCHR and NHRIs are there to provide the State with necessary technical advice and to support in
ensuring that at least a minimum standard is achieved by the State and that is essential to ensure the upholding
of human dignity.
38