highlighted Christchurch and other parts of the South Island as places where
migrants may be more exposed to overt racism. Participants considered these
regions to have less ethnic diversity and exposure to different cultures in comparison
to Auckland. Some also noted that within smaller regions across the country,
awareness of racism toward migrants was low and responses to racism were
considered an urban issue.
I think a lot of people that live here [small region] see New Zealand-wide messaging as
just “Oh that's Wellington and Auckland stuff” and we're totally removed from that, it
doesn't apply to us. (Provider)
4.5.
Belief that racism in Aotearoa New Zealand is not as bad as other countries
Many participants did not feel that racism toward migrants in Aotearoa New Zealand
was a major issue when compared with other countries.
It's not as extreme as other countries, but you do face it every day in New Zealand in your
life... (Chinese focus group)
The latter quote supports this view although it is important to note that the
examples provided are in fact no different to Māori genocide and the Christchurch
terror attacks. It is also important to note the media analysis suggested the
minimisation of racism in this country can depict a sense of denial that racism exists
and an excuse to not address it (see Appendix 2).
We have to differentiate between New Zealand, the United States of America, and
Australia. Here is much better. The Treaty of Waitangi helps. In Australia they can’t even
apologise. They were shooting them like birds. (African focus group)
Mature Pacific participants specifically noted that racism in Aotearoa New Zealand
was not as bad as during the 1970s ‘Dawn Raids’ era when Pacific peoples and
migrants that overstayed their working visas were targeted and forcefully deported.
Like look at our history - our Pacific people came to New Zealand and they came to work,
had no citizenships and got to the point when they were deported...Racism doesn’t
happen here - we only heard about it when we were in Samoa when our people were
being deported back to Samoa [during the Dawn Raids]. (Samoan focus group)
In this light, it is important to note that some mature participants were less likely to
consider racism an issue. As described by some young participants this may be due
to mature people viewing differential outcomes as being the result of individual
choices, rather than inter-generational racialisation and trauma, being less exposed
to social media and more likely to socialise and connect with smaller social groups
and networks that protect them.
In my opinion, it’s increased. I understand if our elders aren’t aware of it because I think
they aren’t exposed to the news, social media...But us young ones, we read the news every
day, we can ascertain what is racism and what is not. (Samoan focus group)
www.malatest-intl.com
Drivers of racism – March 2021
45