Insights and Reflections on the CHR National Inquiry on RH
Commissioner Karen S. Gomez-Dumpit
I would begin this insights and reflection by giving thanks to all who participated
in the activities of the Commission on Human Rights’ National Inquiry on Reproductive
Health and Rights. To our fifteen regional offices who conducted the regional
consultations, to the five CHR regional offices, particularly regions V, VIII, IX, X and NCR
who undertook the fact finding and public hearings, to the different organizations,
government agencies and individuals who made the consultations productive and
meaningful. I am thankful too, to the members of the community who participated during
the fact finding and public hearings who opened their doors, their hearts and minds, and
shared their stories, specially our partners Likhaan Center for Women and Sarilaya.
Thank you for braving many obstacles not just political, but also economic and physical
barriers to your being with us in the fact finding and public hearings.
First, let me share my reflections, particularly the negative ones. Because we are in human
rights work we always look for what’s lacking, we look or gaps and we always look at the
glass half empty.
I witnessed different forms of discrimination during the conduct of the National
Inquiry on RH. I have seen discrimination on the basis of disability, economic status, SOGI,
ethnicity and discrimination on the basis of perhaps religious belief. More than
discrimination, I am disturbed by another ‘D,’ one that is more deliberate. In some of the
areas I have seen the “deliberate disregard” for women’s choices, the disregard of
women’s right to have a choice. This disregard I have seen from one particular local
government unit. I am specifically disturbed by the disregard and disrespect for women
in Sorsogon City were we have seen how women were not allowed the wide range of
choices even when they are in fact available. I am disturbed with Sorsogon because the
situation does not only affect family planning they are also targeting vaccinations for our
children.
It is disturbing because we would want to see a local government unit that would
create an enabling environment. Local Government Units are mandated to provide the
whole range of reproductive services, not to favor one over the other, especially when the
services and resources are available. While we have established that the Department of
3