68
The Independent Commission for Human Rights - ICHR
2. Detention without due process of law (illegal detention)
In some cases, the law allows to deprive individuals of their personal liberty to satisfy an overriding
a legitimate public interest. A case in point in the enforcement of criminal laws. However, the law
prohibits illegal deprivation of personal liberty without causes prescribed by law or without due
process of law. The most important measure to be observed when a person is arrested or detained is
a warrant duly issued by a competent authority. Only in cases of flagrante delicto can a person be
arrested without adequate warrant. The law also requires that the accused be informed of the reasons
for their arrest or detention and of the charge imputed to them at the time of the arrest. In all cases,
the person arrested or detained over a criminal charge must be promptly brought before the competent court for disposition of the legality of their arrest or detention.
In practice, however, security agencies continued to arrest or detain individuals without obtaining
warrants from competent judicial bodies, namely, the Public Prosecution and courts. In clear contravention to the law, security agencies did so in cases other than flagrant offences, rendering such
detention illegal.
Including 74 in the West Bank and 80 in the Gaza Strip, there were 154 claims of detention without
adequate warrant. According to 19 claims, detained persons were not informed of the reasons for
their arrest or of the charges imputed to them (18 in the West Bank and 1 in Gaza). Claims of failure
to bring detained persons before competent courts totalled 58 (48 in the West Bank and 10 in Gaza).
Violations of guarantees of lawful detention also involved prohibition against communicating with
the outside world (32) and denial of access to a legal counsel (6).
Chart 10: Patterns of illegal detention
160
152
140
120
100
80
58
60
40
16
20
0
Detention
without
adequate
warrant
32
6
Failure to state Failure to bring Prohibition Denial of access
reasons of
detained
against
to a legal
detention
persons before communicating
counsel
competent
with the
courts
outside
etention in two years
Chart 11: Claims of illegal detention: 2020-2021
320
310
300
The Situation of Human Rights290
in Palestine
280
307