Other submissions highlighted that face masks exacerbate many of the ableist attitudes in society
around communicating with Deaf or hard of hearing people. Face coverings that completely obscure
mouths further reduce effective communication for some disabled people, and within submissions
there are calls to make clear face shields more common and easily accessible:
“People are facing ableist and audist attitudes when it comes to other people
communicating with us Deaf. People (general society) need to learn basic NZSL and
learn how to communicate with Deaf people (there are a range of ways). There also
needs to be an infrastructure in place for scenarios where it really is good to be able to
see someone’s face and lipread and for facial expressions, e.g. more plexiglass shields,
more face shielding.” (Submission)
The right to a mask exemption is important for many disabled people. Some submissions highlighted
that navigating the process for mask exemptions was unnecessarily difficult and stigmatising,
particularly in education settings (such as schools):
“Families were scrambling for information and applying for exemptions before term
one started as there had been no communication from schools specifically for families
of children with additional needs… [they were] grouped with the concerns raised
by families wishing for freedom to not wear masks (for a variety of reasons) which is
distressing and unfair.” (Submission)
Some submissions also highlighted issues around navigating processes for vaccine exemptions:
“This is an area where I think the space is really difficult. There is not a lot of knowledge
around that mask and vaccine and other exemptions do exist for a reason…there’s not
a lot of acknowledgement that genuine exemptions exist and that people are not just
being anti-maskers or anti-vaxxers.” (Submission)
“People who have suffered an adverse reaction after a medical treatment need special
consideration to assess the risks of them having further treatment with the same
medicine, or whether another approach should be adopted. The very narrow approach
to exemptions creates extreme difficulties for those who have suffered vaccine
injuries or post vaccine injuries which may have been caused or contributed to by the
vaccine... The government’s ‘one size fits all’ approach towards management of COVID,
accordingly discriminates against and has particularly serious adverse effects for
people with disabilities, vaccine injuries or other special needs.” (Submission)
26
Inquiry into the Support of Disabled People and Whānau During Omicron