The Independent Commission for Human Rights (ICHR) | Shadow report
– Coordinate with local institutions to provide education to detained
juveniles. In this context, current efforts are inadequate.
o
Women’s detention centres
– Increase coordination and networking with community institutions and
civil society organisations to rehabilitate and train women to help them
take care of themselves before release.
– Provide a gynaecological clinic or a female gynaecologist for female
inmates independently of the general clinic.
– In relation to the National Preventive Mechanism against Torture
On 29 December 2017, the State of Palestine acceded to the Optional Protocol
to the Convention against Torture (OPCAT), which aims at establishing a
national preventive mechanism against torture (NPM). However, the legal
framework for the NPM, namely the Law by Decree No. 25 of 2022 on the
National Commission against Torture, was only enacted in mid-2022. Together
with civil society groups, the ICHR submitted a position paper on the NPM
establishment as mandated in the law by decree. The ICHR emphasises the
following points, which run counter to the standards of independence and
impartiality prescribed by the OPCAT:
a) Many provisions of the law by decree undermine the principles of NPM
independence. It views the NPM as a State institution and government
agency, to which all laws and regulations on official institutions are applicable.
The enactment also deems that the chairperson and staff members of the
Commission against Torture as civil servants, who are subject to the Civil
Service Law. Procurement and tendering transactions are governed by the
Public Procurement Law, treating the Commission as a full government
body. Every time, NPM members are appointed by the President based
on a recommendation of the Council of Ministers, contradicting the State
of Palestine’s obligations under the OPCAT. These require the adoption
of the highest standards of transparency and independence. When NPM
members are chosen, the same approach applicable to the selection
of commissioners of national human rights institutions will be in place.
Many irregularities deprive the NPM of independence, impartiality, and
objectivity at all levels.
b) The law by decree greatly undermines the independence, transparency,
and impartiality of the National Commission against Torture, which is
established in accordance with its provisions. The law by decree does not
make available the legal tools the Commission needs to exercise its powers
12