Recent announcements made by the Meeting of Attorneys-General32 to develop national principles
around a common understanding of coercive control and to explore criminalisation is the latest example
of a system that prioritises criminal and punitive approaches over healing ones to respond to violence.
This announcement was made despite concerns from many Aboriginal women about the
disproportionate impact of criminalisation on First Nations peoples and evidence that the
misidentification of First Nations women as the predominant aggressor in family violence situations
continues.33 Significant evidence of racism in policing and the justice system has not been addressed and
will especially impact Indigenous women.34
Improving responses to violence requires a whole of system approach spanning
primary prevention through to tertiary responses
Policy built primarily on the assumption that all violence perpetrated in First Nations communities is by
First Nations men echoes a colonial legacy of policies that ignore reports of violence experienced by First
Nations women when it is not perpetrated by First Nations men. It also contributes to a First Nations led
service system that is simultaneously underfunded and over-relied upon.
While research into family violence shows that primary prevention and early intervention is critical to
breaking the cycle of violence, this is one of the least resourced areas in the service system. In remote
areas, ‘drive in and drive out’ services are reliant on women’s services on the ground, increasing the
burden of responsibility on under resourced and overworked services to facilitate connection and
enable primary prevention services to build rapport and achieve positive outcomes for community.
A whole of system response also requires flexible funding that acknowledges the holistic nature of
services and inter-connectedness of family violence prevention work.
There is also a chronic lack of recognition, value and support of the unpaid care work that First Nations
women do in communities, including supporting victims of violence and filling the gaps that inadequate
services and policy induced poverty (particularly through the welfare system) create. Much greater
support and value needs to be placed on this care work, which is often informally given, but critical to
addressing family violence.
There is also a clear role and responsibility for mainstream organisations to prevent and address
violence. Non-First Nations organisations need to better educate themselves around First Nations family
violence responses and be better in providing safe spaces for First Nations people. Often the health
system is the first and only point of contact with professionals for First Nations women experiencing
violence. However, we also know that mainstream primary health care providers do not adequately
respond to First Nations women experiencing violence.35 There are examples of misdiagnosis or
minimisation of First Nations women’s health conditions where medical interaction may be so culturally
unsafe as to heighten women’s health conditions or even lead to preventable deaths.36
Wiyi Yani U Thangani • First Nations Women’s Safety Policy Forum • Outcomes Report | 31