From Four Nodes of History: The Human Rights Challenge in the Philippine Security Sector
8.
What was the Bates Treaty? How did
it affect the efforts for the unification
of the Filipino people towards nationhood
and independence?
The Bates Treaty was a desperate but successful US initiative
aimed at preventing the Moros from joining the revolutionary
forces in Luzon and the Visayas. Such an alliance would have
opened a new fighting front in the Sulu and Mindanao, the
effects of which the US would not have been able to handle.
The revolutionary forces had liberated and established a revolutionary government in Zamboanga under General Vicente
Alvarez. Though it had been overthrown with a counterforce
supported by US Captain Pratt, the revolutionary remnants in
Zamboanga had retreated to Basilan, a vassal island of Sultan
Kiram of Sulu.
The American forces feared the strategic implications posed
by General Alvarez.
When the Spanish forces surrendered Zamboanga on May
18, 1899 (after burning the city to the ground), Alvarez was
proclaimed the head of the revolutionary government in
Zamboanga at a time when the Philippine-American War was
20
American treachery
I
n the Tausug version of the treaty,
no sovereignty issue was raised -only an American commitment of
“support, aid and protection of the Jolo
Island and Archipelago” as stated in Article
I of the treaty. This was treacherously
translated in English by the Americans
as “The sovereignty of the United States
over the whole Archipelago of Jolo
and its dependencies is declared and
acknowledged.” The treaty also gave
assurances that the US will not interfere
with the religious belief and practices
of Moros, the administrative control of
Muslim leaders, and their property rights.
This meant the US could not sell any of
their property.