The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
General Hospital 9 out of 33 posts including that of senior surgeon of child
and ENT are vacant. Many patients are returning home without getting
treatment due to lack of doctors (The Daily Star, 24.11.08).
Absenteeism poses a chronic, but often unmeasured, problem in publicly
financed health care, and can severely limit patient access to services and
suggests corruption (DiTella and Savedoff, 2001). A study conducted by
UNICEF (1992) showed that our doctors spend 54 seconds per patient at
thana hospitals and rural dispensaries; they take 37 seconds per patient to
dispense medicine. The qualified doctors are more inclined to ‘moonlight’
in private clinics where government employed doctors maintain a dual
obligation with their responsibilities (Sobhan, 1998).
Doctors are often criticized for neglecting their duties through absenteeism
and private practice during office hours. Such malpractice generally starts
from the moment of posting of a doctor to a rural THC or Union Health
Centre. They are either unwilling to join, or they make delay within the
loopholes of the system. Given the doctors who join the THCs in rural areas
being dissatisfied with working conditions and career prospects, they look
for alternative ways of earning extra money through private practice and
provide service for less time than the scheduled working hours. Neglect of
duties of the paramedics and domiciliary staff has also been affecting the
policy implementation process (Osman, 2004).
No positive affirmative action is seen to resolve this problem.
i. Poor Management of Drug and Equipment: Misgovernance is prevailing
in the management of drugs and equipment in the public hospitals. A
huge quantity of supplied medicine and equipment is left unutilized and
unconsumed due to poor management. Very often, it is alleged that doctors
encourage the patients to purchase medicine from outside because of the
lack of awareness of the medical officer about availability and quantity of
medicine stocks in the store. Moreover, physicians are getting bribes from
private medicine suppliers. Lack of transparency in management creates
scope for the fourth class employees of the hospitals to sell drugs of hospital
stores to outside pharmacies (Osman, 2004). Many pharmaceutical/drug
shops admit buying medicine from the hospital staff at cheaper rates.
Many private clinics admit procuring expensive equipment and supplies
54
from the public sector supply system (Jahan and Salehin, 2006).
ii. Flow of Funds: Funds allocated for the health sector are scarce and
also are not utilized and managed properly. In many places, bureaucratic
problems, corruption and mismanagement lead to inadequate public
funds at the point of service and the informal charging of patients. The
allocated funds are disbursed very slowly and often at a reduced level. The
slow disbursement of funds causes delayed completion and ineffective
utilization of funds.
In 1993-94, the national health expenditure by both public and private
sectors amounted to 3.04 percent of the GNP. It has increased to 3.4
percent in 2003. Public expenditure on health as a percentage of total
expenditure on health was 36.5 percent in 1998, which has declined to
25.2 percent in 2002. Government health expenditure as a percentage
of the total government expenditure was 6.9 percent in 1998 but it has
also declined to 4.4 percent in 2002. In 1998, the total government health
expenditure per capita was US $ 4, which has increased to US $ 11 in 2002.
iii. Mismanagement in Health Care Service Delivery: Irregularities and poor
governance often simply stem from poor management. Where incentives
for strong performance either do not exist or are undermined by ineffective
management it is not surprising that productivity and performance suffer.
Low wages also lead workers to seek additional employment outside
government (Lewis: 1955).
The promotion path in the Bangladesh public health sector is so long that
employees usually retire before getting promoted to the highest level of
hierarchy, which demoralizes them. Not only the doctors, but field workers
also suffer from such stagnancy of service. There also exists a mismatch in
distribution of human resources between urban and rural areas, which has a
direct impact on the policy performance (Osman, 2004).
Transfer, posting of the health professionals is another problematic area.
In the absence of a clear guideline for transfer/posting, patronage and
corruption is practised in this area. In many cases, transfer and posting
become politically motivated. There is no central training institute for
55