Australian Human Rights Commission
CRPD information concerning Australia – 11.03.13
62.
The Commission notes that issues concerning violence against women with
disability in institutional settings were raised during the UN Special
Rapporteur’s violence against women study tour. 34 The issues include the
heightened vulnerability of women with disability living in group homes, the
perceived impunity surrounding violence by staff or other residents, the
inability to report violence, and the need for appropriate accessible services
and support.
63.
The Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women in its
concluding comments on Australia in 2010, called on the State Party to
undertake a ‘comprehensive assessment of the situation of women with
disabilities in Australia’. To date, this assessment has not been undertaken.
64.
The Commission welcomes the Royal Commission into child sexual abuse in
institutional settings.35 The Commission notes that the terms of reference for
the Royal Commission encompass past and current child sexual abuse and
any related unlawful or improper treatment of children (including children with
disability) in the context of institutions throughout Australia.36 The Commission
notes that unlawful or improper treatment of children unrelated to child sexual
abuse does not come within the terms of reference of the Royal Commission.
4.2
Access to justice (articles 3, 4, 5, 13, 14)
65.
The Commission is concerned about access to justice for people (suspects,
offenders, victims and witnesses) with communication impairment. These
people include people with an intellectual disability, people who use
augmentative or alternative forms of communication, people with Acquired
Brain Injury, people with cerebral palsy who have communication problems,
people who are Deaf and use sign language, people who have a hearing
impairment and people who have little or no speech.
66.
The issues include the capacity of people with communication impairment to
give evidence and to initiate or defend proceedings, and the treatment of
people with communication impairment by police, judges, lawyers and other
court personnel. The Commission is also concerned about the accessibility of
court processes such as access to interpreters to facilitate communication.
67.
The Commission is particularly concerned about access to justice for
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people with a cognitive impairment. This
issue was highlighted in the Commission’s Social Justice Report 2012.37 The
report notes that:
In some Australian jurisdictions, when people with cognitive impairment are found
unfit to plead to criminal charges, they become subject to mental health
legislation. In several jurisdictions, the result for some Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander people with a cognitive impairment accused of crimes for which
they are unable to plead and stand trial, has been indefinite detention.38
68.
Additionally, Aboriginal and Torres Strait people with cognitive impairment,
their families, and communities are not provided with appropriate support and
little help, especially in remote locations.39
12