Part I Experiences of being lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex in the Asia Pacific
186 187
CASE STUDY: RESPONDING TO DISCRIMINATION IN EMPLOYMENT
In 2013, the Bandhu Social Welfare Society worked closely with the
National Human Rights Commission of Bangladesh (JAMAKON) to initiate a
telephone legal help service. JAMAKON has developed a manual for gender
and sexual minorities, explaining its role and work on sexual orientation and
gender identity issues, and encouraging people to file complaints if they face
discrimination.186 In January 2015, JAMAKON succeeded in securing legal
redress for Sohel Rana, a transgender woman who had been terminated from
her job at the Bangladesh Medical Studies and Research Institute in May 2013
because of her gender identity. Following JAMAKON’s finding of unlawful
dismissal, Sohel Rana was compensated for lost salary and reinstated to her
former position.187
In 2015, the Government of Bangladesh unveiled a series of special measures for hijras, including jobs
as traffic police officers and loans for members of the community. However, implementation of the job
quota scheme has been ineffective and heavily criticised. Hijras were required to take physical medical
tests and disqualified if they were deemed ‘biologically male’.188
3.4. CRIMINALISATION
In many parts of Asia, including Thailand, Singapore, Cambodia, Nepal and the Philippines, public
nuisance, vagrancy or related laws have been used to harass transgender women arbitrarily. In addition,
in Indonesia and Malaysia, religious police have authority under religious laws to arrest transgender
people under similar provisions.189 Further, in Malaysia, arrests can also be made under state-level
shari’a laws that only apply to Muslims.
The Cambodia Center for Human Rights has documented police extortion of transgender people under
the authority of the Village and Commune Safety Policy 2011. There is no guidance for law enforcers or
the public about appropriate use of this executive edict from the Ministry of Interior.190
Transgender women who have sex with men may still be detained and prosecuted under laws
criminalising homosexuality, even though they identify as women. In countries where sex work is
criminalised, transgender women are frequently targeted under these provisions.
Laws prohibiting cross-dressing still exist in some countries in the Asia Pacific region. Some have
provisions against ‘female impersonation’ and a minority also prohibit ‘male impersonation’, including in
some states in Malaysia. In other parts of the region there have been recent successes in challenging
such laws. In the Pacific, Samoa repealed its cross-dressing provision in March 2013.191 In November
2014, the Court of Appeal of Malaysia declared that cross-dressing provisions in the shari’a law of
Negeri Sembilan state were unconstitutional.192 The civil society group Justice for Sisters had argued
that the provision violated six articles of Malaysia’s Constitution, relating to freedom of expression,
186
See www.nhrc.org.bd/PDF/NHRC%20Manual%20(English)%20(1).pdf.
187
See
www.asia-pacific.undp.org/content/rbap/en/home/ourwork/democratic-governance-and-peacebuilding/successstories/
engaging-with-national-human-rights-institutions-key-to-advancin.html.
188
See
html.
189
Human Rights Watch, “I’m Scared to Be a Woman”: Human Rights Abuses Against Transgender People in Malaysia, 2014.
190
UNDP and USAID, Being LGBT in Asia: Cambodia Country Report, 2014.
191
Crimes Ordinance Act, s. 58N.
192
Syariah Criminal (Negeri Sembilan) Enactment 1992, s. 66.
http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2015/7/2/bangladesh-hijras-angry-over-gender-testing-for-government-positions.
Chapter 3: Being transgender in Asia and the Pacific | 53