4. Discrimination law reform
Australia’s discrimination laws are complex and
include some operational quirks; have gaps in their
coverage; and, in some cases, have been limited
or further complicated by judicial decisions.
Proposals put forward under this pillar seek
to enhance the operation of discrimination
laws as they currently are, but also pave the
way for further consideration of long term and
substantial reforms.
Several are technical in nature, designed
to improve clarity and consistency across
the various discrimination laws and in their
practical applications, and to reduce the level
of complexity across the system overall.
Importantly, the Commission also proposes
measures to close the existing gaps in
discrimination law coverage to ensure that
everyone is protected from discrimination.
This includes by supporting the introduction of
a new federal ground of unlawful discrimination
based on freedom of thought, conscience and
religion, to be appropriately balanced alongside
existing discrimination grounds in accordance
with Australia’s international obligations, as
illustrated in Text Box 3.
Text Box 3: The need for religious discrimination protection
The Commission has publicly called for protections against discrimination and vilification on
the basis of religious belief for over 25 years. For example, a recommendation for religious
discrimination protections was presented to the Parliament in 1998.17
In May 2018, an independent expert panel finalised a Religious Freedom Review which
recommended that the Australian Government should amend the Racial Discrimination Act
1975, or enact a Religious Discrimination Act, to render it unlawful to discriminate on the basis
of a person’s ‘religious belief or activity’, including on the basis that a person does not hold any
religious belief.18
Various drafts of Religious Discrimination bills have been developed since 2018 and have been
open to public consideration through consultation processes. The Commission has contributed
views on each draft Bill.19
A Bill protecting against religious discrimination has yet to be passed by the federal Parliament.
While there are some protections against religious discrimination in federal, State and Territory
law, these protections are incomplete. In some situations, such as complaints to the Commission
of religious discrimination in employment, existing legal protections do not provide for
enforceable remedies where discrimination is established.
Just as Australians are provided with statutory protection against discrimination on the grounds
of race, sex, disability and age, so too should they be provided with equivalent protection
against discrimination on the ground of religious belief or activity. This reinforces the idea,
reflected in Article 2 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, that human rights are
indivisible and universal.
Prohibiting discrimination on the ground of religious belief or activity (including beliefs about
religion held by people who are atheists or agnostics) is consistent with, and supports, the
tolerant, pluralistic nature of Australian society.
Box continued over
FREE & EQUAL: Revitalising Australia’s Commitment to Human Rights
89