2 About the Guidance Resource
2.1 Who is the Guidance
Resource for?
The Guidance Resource is intended to provide
guidance to professionals and businesses who
are using AI when making insurance pricing and
underwriting decisions. It has been developed for
actuaries, insurance companies, their staff, and
others working in this area.
The Guidance Resource does not constitute legal
advice. It only provides general guidance and
is not a definitive legal answer to all issues of
discrimination that may arise. There is limited legal
certainty about how a court may decide many of
these issues. Given these constraints, the Guidance
Resource indicates when the Commission considers
that conduct ‘may’ or is ‘likely’ to constitute unlawful
discrimination.
Ultimately, an insurer’s board of directors and
Organisations or individuals should seek their own
corporate officers are responsible for ensuring
the insurer’s compliance with anti-discrimination
law. This Guidance Resource may help to create a
common understanding between such executives
and practitioners of these issues, aiding discussion
of it within insurers.
independent legal advice if they have concerns
regarding their compliance with federal, state or
territory anti-discrimination legislation.
The Guidance Resource may also assist customers
of insurance companies and members of the public
in understanding their rights in this context.
2.2 Why should I consider the
Guidance resource?
The Guidance Resource provides information
and practical guidance to assist decision makers
to comply with their obligations under federal
anti-discrimination legislation when using AI in
insurance pricing and underwriting decisions.
There are important reasons for following the
Guidance Resource. It is against the law to
discriminate against a person because of protected
attributes, such as their age, sex, race, or disability,
when providing insurance services unless an
exemption applies.
An organisation or individual will not be protected
from a finding of unlawful discrimination by
claiming that they complied with, or relied on, the
Guidance Resource. The Commission considers
however that acting in accordance with the
Guidance Resource represents good practice
and may be a factor considered by the courts,
should a matter be considered in a judicial forum,
particularly when considering if any discrimination
was reasonable in the circumstances. This is an
area of evolving practice, and it is recommended
that insurers stay up to date with any developments
to current practices and the law.
Some insurance products (such as private health
insurance and Compulsory Third Party (CTP)
insurance) are underwritten as part of statutory
schemes which may impose significant restrictions
over terms, conditions, or prices of policies. This
Guidance Resource is written in general terms
considering typical insurance products, and does
not consider the specific details that apply to such
products or schemes.
Institute members may find it a useful resource to
assist in complying with relevant laws as required
under the Institute’s Code of Conduct.
Guidance Resource: Artificial intelligence and discrimination in insurance pricing and underwriting • 2022 • 9