No
connection
RF
DK/NA
Male
29.17%
10.42%
29.69%
0.52%
1.30%
28.91%
Female
36.04%
10.52%
30.15%
0.56%
0.98%
21.74%
Total
33.70%
10.63%
29.88%
0.54%
1.09%
24.16%
Yes
No
Sometimes
Table 14: Perceived conflict between Islamic views and human rights, by gender
There is no change in the number of respondents
who said there is no connection between Islam and
human rights (1.00%) while the response rate to
the question has also not improved (15.9% in 2011
compared to 25.2% in 2019). This is a significantly
worrying change in perception and one that
demands strengthened policy and programmatic
interventions.
Similar to 2011 findings, more women (36.0%) than
men (29.2%), were of the opinion that human rights
are incompatible with Islam. There is significant
decrease in respondents who said human rights
and Islam were compatible (45.0% in 2011 to
29.9% in 2019). This holds true with all sexes. The
number of women agreeing with compatibility
between Islam and human rights decreased from
41.0% in 2011 to 30.2% in 2019, while the figure for
men fell from 49.0% in 2011 to 29.7% in 2019. It is
also to be noted that men (30.2%) appeared more
hesitant to respond to this query in comparison to
women (22.7%).
No
connection
RF
DK/NA
Outer
island
No
Table 15: Conflict between Islamic views and human rights, by region
Sometimes
There is an increase in the number of people who
believe human rights are incompatible with Islam
(from 29.6% in 2011 to 33.7% in 2019), while a
decline is observed in the those who think it is
compatible (from 45.6% in 2011 to 29.9% in 2019).
Over a third (35.6%) of the respondents living in
urban regions were of the belief that there are no
conflicts between human rights and Islam, while
26.4% of those from outer islands subscribe to
this view. This shows a significant decline in the
number of respondents living in urban regions
who believe there is no conflict between human
rights and Islam from 2011 (54.0%). Over a third
(34.0%) of the respondents from outer islands
stated that they believed human rights and
Islam are in conflict and hence incompatible.
Yes
Given the significance of perception on successful
implementation of policies and interventions,
HRCM decided it was important to understand
how people perceived the relationship between
Islam and human rights to facilitate the effective
implementation of Human Rights in the Maldives.
As the findings from other chapters show,
attitudes on women and family life appear to have
a significant correlation with religion. An additional
factor considered was the high non-response rate
from the 2011 survey on questions pertaining
to Islam and human rights; this prompted the
inclusion of these questions in this survey.
34.02%
10.46%
26.36%
0.74%
1.77%
26.66%
Urban
33.18%
10.90%
35.55%
0.24%
0.00%
20.14%
Total
33.70%
10.63%
29.88%
0.54%
1.09%
24.16%
Among those who considered human rights to
be non-compliant with Islam, 50.0% were from
the 60-69 age group. Interestingly, the greatest
number of people who thought human rights
and Islam are compatible were over 70 years of
age (41.7%). This age group is also the lowest
(25.0%) to report that there is conflict between
human rights and Islam. It is notable that over
a third (36.2%) of the respondents who think
human rights and Islam are not compatible
belong to the age group of 20-29 years.
Among migrant workers, 15.5% believe human
rights to be compatible with Islam. However,
it is to be noted that most migrant workers
(75.3%) did not respond or know the answer to
this query.
Those who replied that human rights are not
compatible with Islam were further queried
about the reasons for their stance. Close to a
half of the respondents believed that human
rights are not compatible with Islam because
the punishments for offences prescribed in
Islam conflict with principles of human rights.
Several people also said it is problematic that
human rights impede the implementation of
death penalty. There were worrying responses
from a considerable number of people who felt
that gender equality and child rights are not
compatible with Islam. It is more concerning
that most of these respondents were women.
27