NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
a decision to eliminate his entire family. Hence, the Commission was of the view that the
loss of family of Mahender due to Police negligence amounted to a violation of his human
rights. In the circumstances, the Chief Secretary, Government of Haryana was directed to
show cause u/s 18 (a) (i) of PHR Act, 1993 as to why a compensation of ` 1,00,000/- should
not be recommended to be paid to the victim.
4.44 Vide its further proceedings dated 14.03.2018, the Commission directed the Govt of
Haryana to submit the compliance report.The matter is under consideration of the Commission.
7)
Death of one Villager Ismail Miah in Firing by BSF in Ram Nagar, Tripura
(Case No.19/23/4/2015-PF)
4.45 Shri Duryodhana Reddy, a human rights activist has drawn the attention of the
Commission towards a newspaper report published in “The Hindu” on 08.06.2014 relating to
the death of a villager, Ismile Miah in firing by the BSF on 07.06.2014 at Ramnagar in Tripura.
It was alleged that no ex-gratia amount was paid to the family of the deceased as yet.
4.46 Pursuant to the directions of the Commission, the Director-General of Police reported
that the complaint was inquired into by the Superintendent of Police, West Tripura. 06.06.2014,
some villagers were passing their time in the open air near the NAKA point. At around 8:30
p.m., Constable Sandeep Kumar, suddenly came and started arguing with the villagers. When
one Mr. Kanu Miah protested against the behaviour of the jawan, the said BSF jawan thrashed
him and left. When an alarm was raised in this regard, many villagers instantly gathered at
the spot. At this juncture, Constable Sandeep Kumar, suddenly advanced from NAKA Point
towards the villagers and began firing indiscriminately from his service weapon without
any caution to the villagers. On account of the indiscriminate firing, the victim died at the
spot and more than 12 civilians received injuries. A large number of people also assembled
there and seeing the scenario the said BSF constable committed suicide using his service rifle.
A case under section 302/307/326 and 28 of the Arms Act was registered against the BSF
personnel who got abated on account of death. An amount of ` 120,000 was sanctioned for
cost of medicine in connection with treatment of 10 injured persons by SDM, Sadar and an
amount of ` 15,000 (Rupees fifteen thousand only) was paid to the wife of deceased victim.
4.47 The Commission considered the matter on 22.05.2017 and observed that it stands
established that the victim died on account of the injuries suffered in the indiscriminate firing
by the BSF soldier on 6 June 2014. The compensation of ` 15,000 rendered by the SDM, Sadar
is highly inadequate. Hence, the Commission directed the Government of Tripura to pay a
compensation of ` 3,00,000 to the family of the victim.
4.48
52
The compliance report is awaited.
Annual Report 2017-2018