Chapter 1 – Report of the Policy, Law and Complaints Group
in Malaysia,46 the Commission recommends that such rights be extended to all refugees
who are already present in Malaysia.
(e)
Detention under Preventive Laws
In 2015, the Commission continued to observe the use of preventive laws, namely the
Prevention of Crime Act 1959 (POCA), the Dangerous Drugs Act (Special Preventive
Measures) 1985 (DDASPM), the Security Offences (Special Measures) Act 2012 (SOSMA)
and the newly enacted Prevention of Terrorism Act 2015 (POTA). While the Commission
supports the Government’s efforts to tackle serious crime and curb terrorism, the Commission
stresses that all laws should be in line with human rights principles. The Commission had
expressed its concerns that these laws infringed fundamental rights by allowing preventive
detention, thereby violating a person’s right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty and
to be given a free and fair trial before a competent court.
In 2015, the Commission received eight complaints involving detention under POCA, five
under the DDASPM, and one under SOSMA. In most of these cases, the Commission had
written to the Ministry of Home Affairs (MOHA) forwarding the appeals of the complainants
and highlighting the Commission’s stance on the laws as well as emphasising the rights of
the detainees to be tried in an open court of law as guaranteed under the Constitution and
the UDHR. The Ministry responded to several of the Commission’s letters by informing the
Commission that the appeals of the complainants had been forwarded to the Board of Crime
Prevention and the Advisory Board for consideration.
On 11 November, the Commission received a memorandum from Suara Rakyat Malaysia
(SUARAM) on the misuse of SOSMA to detain and torture suspects of terrorism. The
family of one of the suspects detained under SOSMA, Mr. Nor Azmi bin Jalani, claimed that
he had been tortured mentally and physically during his 28-day detention under SOSMA
at the Police Remand Centre (PRC) in April. As part of the inquiry into the complaint, the
Commission recorded Mr. Azmi’s statement at Sungai Buloh Prison on 25 November.
During the recording, the Commission discovered that there were three other detainees who
allegedly went through similar torture while being detained together under SOSMA. They
are Mr. Hadrami bin Hashim, Mr. Mohd Yusri bin Mohamed Yusof and Mr. Ali Saifuddin. The
Commission recorded the statements of the three at Sungai Buloh Prison on 22 December.
Among the allegations made by the four detainees are that:
46
“Malaysia accepting 3,000 Syrian refugees on humanitarian grounds, says Zahid”, New Straits Times, viewed at,
http://www.nst.com.my/news/2015/10/malaysia-accepting-3000-syrian-refugees-humanitarian-grounds-sayszahid?utm_source=nst&utm_medium=nst&utm_campaign=nstrelated on 2 October; “Malaysia to offer shelter,
jobs, education to Syrian refugees”, Astro Awani, viewed at http://english.astroawani.com/malaysia-news/malaysiaoffer-shelter-jobs-education-syrian-refugees-64005 on 2 October.
93
BOOK-ANR2016-01-latest.indb 93
08/04/2016 3:32 PM