Chapter 1 – Report of the Policy, Law and Complaints Group
According to the Lock-Up Rules 1953, medical screening by a medical officer is compulsory
when a suspect is detained in a police lock-up. However, this has never been implemented
because there has never been a medical officer placed at the police lock-ups. Besides that,
there are no police personnel who have been trained to handle issues related to healthcare,
and no medical facilities available at the police lock-ups.
(ii)
Conditions of the Lock-Ups
The Commission observed that the conditions of the lock-ups were very degrading and did
not meet international standards. Most of the lock-ups visited during the study had very
poor ventilation and lighting. This caused a bad smell in the lock-ups and might have been
a contributing factor to the poor health of the detainees. Cleanliness was also observed to
be poor and the toilets were in very deplorable conditions.
The floor surfaces of the lock-ups, which were of either wood or cement, were not properly
maintained, limiting the living space of the detainees. The situation would worsen when the
lock-ups were overcrowded, leaving detainees limited space for sleep.
(iii) Meals
Most of the detainees interviewed during the study complained about the meals provided at
the lock-ups. Detainees were provided three meals a day - breakfast, lunch, and dinner - but
according to the detainees the food and water that were provided to them were not enough.
Packed water was provided during meals but more often than not it was not sufficient. The
Commission found that the detainees were asked to drink tap water from the toilets if they
requested for more water. The main contributing factor to this problem was the low budget
allocated for the meals by the Government. The Commission also noted that the allocation
varied from district to district, with some receiving an unbelievably low amount.
(iv) Overcrowding
The Commission observed that most of the lock-ups, especially the older ones, were constantly
facing the problem of overcrowding. This was due to the size of the lock-ups, which limited
the number of detainees that could be accommodated. The problem would worsen when
there were operations and raids by authorities - not only PDRM, but also agencies such as
the Immigration Department of Malaysia (IMM), the Royal Malaysian Customs Department
(RMCD), the Malaysia Maritime Enforcement Agency (MMEA), and religious enforcement
authorities. These agencies usually use police lock-ups as a transit facility or for temporary
detention. Overcrowding could lead to problems like infighting among detainees, the risk
of getting infectious diseases, lack of sleeping space and lack of proper monitoring by the
authorities.
74
BOOK-ANR2016-01-latest.indb 74
08/04/2016 3:32 PM