ball partners, uniforms, and anti-discrimination
policies).308 Research suggests that sporting
and physical education contexts can be some
of the most unsafe environments for SOGIESCdiverse young people.309 This is related to the
highly gendered and binary organisation of some
sports, and the overt homophobia, biphobia, and
transphobia pervasive in these spaces.310
In addition, there is a lack of relevant support
groups and safe spaces within schools.311
Qualitative research on gay and bisexual Pasifika
men’s experiences of school-based support
services showed that participants wanted staff
to do more to support them, such as undergo
professional development in SOGIESC diversity, as
well as cultural competency training for working
with Pasifika students.312 All participants described
the need for increased visibility and safe spaces
in their school environments. In a recent report
from the Education Review Office, some school
boards stated that they “didn’t have any” students
with diverse sexual orientations, gender identities
and expressions, or sex characteristics,313 despite
extensive national and international research to
the contrary.314 Such statements are usually used
as an excuse to refrain from protecting students
of diverse identities and to exclude content
relevant to them.315 Where schools do have active
support groups for SOGIESC-diverse students,
research suggests that these can be both safe
and empowering. In some schools, these groups
engage in educating other students and teachers
about SOGIESC diversity and inclusion.316
“SEXUAL EDUCATION IS ALL
SUPER STRAIGHT AND NOT
QUEER, TRANS, OR INTERSEX
FRIENDLY. IT’S ‘CONDOM ON
A BANANA,’ SHOWING PEOPLE
VIDEOS FROM THE 1980s, OR
GRAPHIC PHOTOGRAPHS OF
GENITALIA WITH SEXUALLY
TRANSMITTED INFECTIONS.”
The New Zealand Curriculum
The Ministry of Education’s 2007 New Zealand
Curriculum places emphasis on values, including
diversity; requiring that students learn to respect
themselves, others, and human rights.317 In 2015,
the Ministry of Education published the Te Kete
Ipurangi Guidelines, providing examples of good
practice age-appropriate content that should be
taught at each level of the school curriculum, from
Year 1 to Year 13.318 The aim of the guidelines is to
support the inclusion and wellbeing of students
with diverse sexual orientations, gender identities
and expressions, and sex characteristics. The
same year, the Ministry published a guide for
principals, Boards of Trustees, and teachers
regarding sexuality education.319 That guide
outlines how schools should go about teaching
Nine to Noon “Determinants for academic success among LGBT students” (podcast, 12 November 2019) Radio New Zealand
<https://www.rnz.co.nz/>
309
Erik Denison and Alistair Kitchen “Out on the fields: The first international study on homophobia in sport” (Australian Sports
Commission, Canberra, 2015).
310
Jaimie Veale and others Counting Ourselves: The health and wellbeing of trans and non-binary people in Aotearoa New Zealand
(Transgender Health Research Lab, University of Waikato, Hamilton, 2019) at 66; InsideOUT “Making schools safer for trans and
gender diverse youth” (2016) <www.insideout.org.nz> at 14.
311
Simon Denny and others “The association between supportive high school environments and depressive symptoms and
suicidality among sexual minority students” (2014) 0 Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology p1.
312
Jono Selu “‘THIS TEA IS HOT!’ Pasifika gay & bisexual men’s experiences of school-based support services” (unpublished master’s
thesis, University of Auckland, 2017).
313
Education Review Office Promoting wellbeing through sexuality education (Wellington, 2018) at 10.
314
Victor Madrigal-Borloz Report to the General Assembly by the Independent Expert on protection against violence and discrimination
based on sexual orientation and gender identity UN Doc A/74/181 (17 July 2019) at A; Mathijs Lucassen and others “Youth’12 The
health and wellbeing of secondary school students in New Zealand: Results for young people attracted to the same sex or both
sexes” (The University of Auckland, Auckland, 2014).
315
Education Review Office Promoting wellbeing through sexuality education (Wellington, 2018).
316
Hayley McGlashan and Katie Fitzpatrick “LGBTQ youth, activism, and school: Challenging sexuality and gender norms” (2017) 117
Health Education Journal p485.
317
Ministry of Education The New Zealand Curriculum (Wellington, 2007) at 10.
318
Ministry of Education Guide to LGBTIQA+ students (Wellington, 2015).
319
Ministry of Education Sexuality Education: A Guide for Principals, Boards of Trustees and Teachers (Wellington, 2015).
308
51