A focus on equity
The term substantive equality is used in
a human rights context to indicate an
understanding of equality as the elimination of
major inequities. Fredman (2016) proposes that
this means:
…to redress disadvantage; to address
stigma, stereotyping, prejudice and violence;
to enhance voice and participation; and
to accommodate difference and achieve
structural change. Behind this is the basic
principle that the right to equality should be
located in the social context, responsive to
those who are disadvantaged, demeaned,
excluded, or ignored.165
A country’s responsibility to achieve substantive
equality and protect citizens from human rights
violations is an obligation of due diligence.
Goodmark (2018) describes due diligence
in relation to women’s right to be free from
violence and abuse:
Due diligence is more than just passing
legislation or criminalising violence. If
existing law fails to protect women from
violence, states are required to find more
effective measures…prevention requires
that the nation identify and address the
root causes of violence against women,
including gender-based stereotyping and
discrimination and structural economic and
social inequality166.
48
Human Rights Commission
Women With Disabilities Australia (WWDA)
explain that, without the use of a comprehensive
gendered human rights frame, mainstream and
non-specialist efforts to prevent and respond to
violence against women will further marginalise
and disadvantage disabled women and can
increase the risks of systemic violence against
them (violating rights by omission).167
They propose that using a human rights frame
to address violence against disabled people:
•
recognises violence against disabled people
as a violation of rights
•
recognises the multiple and intersecting
forms of discrimination that both enable
violence to occur and are created by
experiencing violence
•
specifies and prioritises communities
facing discriminatory and disproportionate
burdens of violence
•
commits to core human rights principles of
non-discrimination, and self-determination
and participation by those most affected.168
The recommendations target “root causes”169
of violence against disabled people as well as
the gaps in data, service provision and sector
knowledge and skills.