Annual Report 1999-2000
was informed that the Chief Medical Officer, Rai Bareilly, was found negligent for not
obtaining the Medico-Legal Expert Report promptly. An adverse remark had also been
noted in his confidential file.
From the reports, the Commission noted that the bodily remains of the deceased were
handed over to the complainant nine months after the death; this had resulted in mental
agony to her and forced her to rush to Rai Bareilly to contact the authorities. The
Commission held that this avoidable delay was directly attributable to the gross negligence
of the State authorities at different levels. In the circumstances, the Commission
recommended the payment of interim compensation of Rs. 10,000/- to the complainant
by the Government of Uttar Pradesh within two months. The State Government has since
paid the compensation.
Death of an innocent person owing to negligence of the state electricity board: Bihar
(Case No. 2010/4/98-99)
The Commission received a complaint from Smt Ranjana Singh alias Ranju, a resident
of Daltonganj, Palamu, Bihar, alleging that on 2 August 1996, her husband, Satyabrat
Narain Singh, had come in contact with a live electric wire lying in front of Morehouse
Patna, as a result of which he was electrocuted and had died. She attributed the death
of her husband to the negligence of the Bihar State Electricity Board (BSEB). She also
stated that the BSEB had failed to atvard her any compensation, though in a similar
case, the Supreme Court had awarded compensation. The complainant stated that she was
facing an acute financial crisis, and was on the verge of starvation, and was also unable
to meet the expenditure required for the education of her minor sons. She sought an
enquiry into the matter and of suitable compensation to be awarded to her.
In response to the notice, the Government of Bihar, in its report, stated that the late
Satyabrat Narain Singh, husband of the complainant,, had died of electrocution at
Rajinder Nagar, Patna, for which a case dated 5 August 1996 was registered at the Kadam
Kuan Police Station, Patna. The report also brought out that the post-mortem on the
body of the deceased had been conducted at Patna Medical College and Hospital and
that the cause of death was stated to be electrocution. The report of the Secretary, BSEB,
confirmed that the L.T. line and live wire of the transmission/distribution line of the
Bihar State Electricity Board was broken due to a heavy storm on 2 August 1996, and
that Shri Satyabrat Narain Singh had touched the live wire and had died due to
electrocution. The report also stated that no compensation was paid to the wife of the
deceased by the BSEB, as her husband had died following a natural calamity.
The Commission noted that there was no material on record to show that the storm,
which had allegedly led to the breaking of the live wire, was of such intensity or
unprecedented severity in nature, that the concerned authorities responsible for the
installation and maintenance of the transmission/distribution lines, could not have
122