The precarious nature of employment in the
construction industry contributes to Pacific peoples’
unwillingness to engage in health and safety
protocols.244 Pacific workers will not report incidents
or object to managers for fear of losing employment,
which undermines their ability to support and
contribute to the wellbeing of their family and
community outside of work. In many instances,
this is compounded by Pacific construction workers
overworking themselves to please superiors and
maintain a good image and will unwillingly work
overtime when requested to do so.245 As Chen points
out, if Pacific workers had secure work, there would
be little fear of employment loss and lower injury
and overworking rates amongst Pacific construction
workers.246
5.3 Pacific peoples’ experiences in the
workplace: manufacturing
5.3.1 Health and safety and Pacific peoples in
manufacturing
As with the construction industry, research on Pacific
workers’ experiences of the manufacturing industry
is dominated by focusing on workplace health and
safety. The manufacturing industry accounts for
the largest proportion of ACC workplace claims,
with Māori and Pacific workers consistently having
the highest reporting rates and lowest acceptance
rates.247 The same issues regarding cultural
differences between Pacific and Western workplace
culture are also raised in research on Pacific
experiences of the manufacturing industry that were
raised in research on the construction industry.248
However, the Department of Labour’s 2012 research
paper In Harm’s Way noted that their participants had
a strong understanding of their workplace role and
its health and safety commitments.249
Pacific workers in the manufacturing industry also
raise experiences of miscommunication owing
34
to different cultural rules for speaking to those
in power.250 However, the problem of cultural
disconnect is far more frequently raised by Pākehā
managers in the manufacturing industry than by
Pacific workers themselves. Pacific workers more
often express that their failure to report incidents
or communicate ideas or dissent is due to a fear of
losing their employment or income, precisely because
it impacts their ability to support their family and
community.251 For instance, one employee remarked:
“I’ve had an injury in my back, but I still force myself,
you know, that Samoan thing I got to make this
money for family, can’t complain about it.”252
Since then, the Department of Labour was
integrated into the Ministry of Business, Innovation
and Employment (MBIE). In 2018, MBIE released a
report evaluating the Puataunofo programme253
–a workplace health and safety education initiative
delivered by WorkSafe New Zealand focused on
providing key health and safety messages to Pacific
workers, taking into account the Health and Safety at
Work Act 2015. The evaluation report found that the
programme was constrained in its ability to operate
at scale. It did, however, find that the programme
solved two problems – raising the engagement of
Pacific staff with efforts to promote health and safety
in the workplace and directly supporting businesses
to adapt to the growing diversity of their workforce.
5.3.2 Racism and Pacific peoples in manufacturing
As the Department of Labour notes, the assumption
made by Pākehā employers that Pacific workers
do not report issues or share ideas because they
do not understand their instructions indicates that
racism is evident in the manufacturing industry.254
Pacific manufacturing workers describe feeling as
though they have to conceal their culture to keep
their employment and describe management
as disempowering, unwilling to hear workers’
244
Chen, National Culture, 44.
245
Feilo, “Talanoa,” 67; Chen, National Culture, 43-45.
246
Chen, National Culture, 44.
247
Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, iii, 1; Powell, ACC’s Delivery to Priority Populations: Part 2 - Pāsifika Peoples, 1-2.
248
Chen, National Culture, 42-43; Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 58.
249
Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 30.
250
Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 52, 58.
251
Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 32
253
Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 32.
254
Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 46.