The experiences of Pacific women in the workplace
in relation to discrimination and pay inequity
indicate the existence of the glass ceiling.107 Pacific
women who participated in Tupou’s research shared
negative experiences when discussing promotion
opportunities and pay equity, acknowledging their
ethnic heritage and gender were met with hostility
within the workplace by their supervisors and nonPacific co-workers.108 Studies also show that Pacific
women are more likely to remain in part-time work
than full-time work to meet family or communal
obligations, showing that Pacific women are typically
employed in reduced hours of work.109 Potential
explanations for such findings reflect the cultural
and familial obligations Pacific women carry as
daughters and mothers.110 The increasingly lower
hourly rates of pay for Pacific women reveal that
Pacific women are further marginalised as the lack of
pay equity amongst Pacific women and men means
Pacific women must work more hours to earn the
same amount that Pacific men do. Pacific women
who are the sole providers for their families also
have obligations and commitments to their family
and community that go beyond providing financial
income.111 Such obligations and commitments carry
just as much importance as providing income,
reflecting Pacific values that regard the work of
holding the family together as both esteemed and
valuable.112
the average hourly rates of different migrant
groups. The survey found that there is not only a
gap between workers originating from overseas and
those from Aotearoa New Zealand but also between
workers from different overseas countries.114 More
specifically, it found that migrants from South Africa,
Northern America, the UK and Europe “all earned
a higher average hourly wage than people born in
New Zealand”.115 By contrast, people born in the
Pacific, Asia and the rest of the Americas earned
significantly lower wages than those born in New
Zealand. This gap persisted no matter how long
migrants from these regions had lived and worked
in Aotearoa New Zealand. For example, it was
reported that engineering professionals from the
UK, South Africa and Northern America all earned
an average wage above $45 an hour. By contrast,
engineering professionals from India, China and the
Pacific Islands all had hourly wages below $40.116
The survey outlined several factors that contribute
to this gap including English language proficiency,
lack of recognition of non-European or American
professional qualifications, institutional barriers
and discrimination.117 While the gendered nature of
migrant pay gaps was beyond the scope of this study,
the report noted that it is “important to understand
how these dynamics change when gender is added
to the equation. Particularly, how these gaps look in
highly feminised industries and occupations”.118
4.2.2 The experiences of Pacific migrants
The literature makes it clear that there needs to
be a focus on the particular experiences of Pacific
migrants in the workforce. Research discussed in
the previous section already noted how gender
shaped the experience of Pacific migrants in the
labour market. Studies show that Pacific migrants
A survey published by Diversity Works NZ and BERL
in 2022 affirmed the persistence of the migrant pay
gap in Aotearoa New Zealand.113 Drawing on data
from the 2013 and 2018 Censuses as well as the
Inland Revenue Department, the report compared
107
‘Glass ceiling’ often refers to an unacknowledged barrier to advancement in a profession: Cotter, David, Joan M. Hermsen,
Seth Ovadia, and Reeve Vanneman. “The glass ceiling effect.” Social Forces 80, no. 2 (2001), 655.
108
Tupou, Holeva. “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling on Pacific Island Women in New Zealand Organisations.” Master’s thesis,
Auckland University of Technology, 2011, 70. https://openrepository.aut.ac.nz/handle/10292/4487.
109
Fa’anunu, Sinama Tupou. “Experiences of Tongan Women Migrants at Paid Work in New Zealand.”(PhD dissertation,
University of Waikato, 2007, 80.
110
Naepi, Sereana. “Pacific Peoples, Higher Education and Feminisms.” In Decolonization and Feminisms in Global Teaching and
Learning, edited by Sara de Jong, Rosalba Icaza, and Olivia Rutazibwa. Abingdon: Routledge, 2018, 17, 21.
111
Fa’anunu, “Experiences of Tongan Women Migrants,” 83.
112
Naepi, “Pacific Peoples, Higher Education and Feminisms,” 11-24.
113
Reid et al. Migrant Pay Gap. Auckland: Diversity Works NZ, 2022. https://diversityworksnz.org.nz/media/5026/migrant-paygap-narrative-report-final.pdf
114
Reid et al., Migrant Pay Gap, 2.
115
Reid et al., Migrant Pay Gap, 2.
116
Reid et al., Migrant Pay Gap, 5.
117
Reid et al., Migrant Pay Gap, 3-6.
118
Reid et al., Migrant Pay Gap, 5.
Pacific Pay Gap Inquiry Literature Review
21