325. In 2016, the Commission identified four principles that should guide the
development of any regime dealing with surrogacy:309
•
the best interests of the child are protected (including the child’s safety
and wellbeing and the child’s right to know about their origins)
•
the surrogate mother is able to make a free and informed decision
about whether to act as a surrogate
•
sufficient regulatory protections are in place to protect the surrogate
mother from exploitation
•
there is legal clarity about the parent-child relationships that result
from the arrangement.
326. A key issue is whether it is possible to make access to safe, well-regulated
domestic surrogacy arrangements easier, so that there is less incentive for
people to enter into potentially less well-regulated arrangements
elsewhere. The Commission submitted that prohibition of surrogacy may
be necessary if international surrogacy arrangements (whether altruistic
or commercial) cannot be effectively regulated. 310
Recommendation 46: Australian Governments achieve consistency
between surrogacy laws and include criteria directed at the suitability of
intended parents. If international surrogacy arrangements are to be
permitted, such checks should also form part of the regulation of those
arrangements. The Australian Government should:
•
continue to engage with the Hague Conference on Private
International Law in relation to the potential for an international
convention dealing with the regulation of parentage and
surrogacy
•
engage with countries where Australians enter into surrogacy
arrangements, for the purpose of determining whether bilateral
agreement can be reached on the regulation of parentage and
surrogacy
•
undertake a systematic review of the structure and enforcement
of regulatory regimes in countries where Australians enter into
surrogacy arrangements.
56