NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS
COMMISSION, INDIA
iv.
v.
vi.
5.
The Commission further observed and directed that the Under Trial Prisoner (UTP) was in
the care and custody of the State, which was responsible to ensure his safety and security.
In this case, the Magistrate has concluded that death of the undertrial prisoner Chunni
Lal is suspicious and occurred due to strangulation and not because of hanging. For this
death due to strangulation, the State is liable to compensate the next- of-kin (Nok) of the
deceased.
The Commission issued a notice u/s 18(a)(i) of The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993,
to the Government of UP, through its Chief Secretary, requiring it to show cause, within
six weeks, as to why the Commission should not make a recommendation for payment of
Rs. 1,00,000/- to the next-of-kin of the deceased undertrial prisoner Chunni Lal, S/o Ram
Awadh.
The reply is awaited.
Death of accused Musan Sahni S/o late Ramaj Sahni in the jurisdiction of PS Singhwada
(Case No. 3676/4/10/2013-PCD)
i.
The Commission received intimation from the Sr. Supdt. of Police, Darbhanga, Bihar
regarding the custodial death of accused Musan Sahni S/o late Ramaj Sahni in the
jurisdiction of PS Singhwada on 23.09.2013.
ii.
Pursuant to the directions of the Commission, the requisite reports were received. The
inquest report revealed abrasions on the back, bruises below the knee and faecal matter
was seen in his dhoti. The post-mortem examination report indicates bruises and abrasions
on the body of the deceased. The histopathological examination report indicates that he
might have died due to heart failure as a result of mayocardial infarction. The magisterial
enquiry concluded that Musan Sahni had died due to heart failure.
iii.
The Commission further observed that although, it was evident that the death of the
deceased had been caused due to mayocardial infraction, as opined by the Department
of Forensic Medicine, Darbhanga Medical College, Leheriasarai, the Police did not fulfill its
moral responsibility to shift the sick accused to the hospital instead of handing him over
to his family members. The Police ought to have evacuated the deceased to the nearest
hospital to save his life, as he was already taken into custody, but it failed to do so, and the
deceased was let off by the Police in complete abdication of its duties and responsibilities.
Such apathy towards a human life amounts to violation of human rights for which the State
is liable to make reparations to the next-of-kin (NoK) of the deceased accused Musan Sahni.
iv.
The Commission has issued a notice under Section 18 of the Protection of Human Rights
Act, 1993 to the Government of Bihar, through its Chief Secretary, requiring it to show
cause within six weeks as to why the Commission should not recommend payment of
Rs.200, 000/- as compensation to the next-of-kin (NoK) of the deceased accused, Musan
Sahni, son of late Shri Ramraj Sahni.
v.
The reply is awaited.
ANNUAL REPORT 2018-19
39