The response of the Department has been published alongside this report. Of the
24 recommendations that have been made by the Commission, the Department
has agreed with two recommendations, disagreed with five recommendations,
and noted the remaining 17. Many of these recommendations reflect similar
recommendations made by the Commission in past reports, and are consistent with
recommendations made by other oversight bodies, such as the Commonwealth
Ombudsman. We would welcome the opportunity to discuss ways the Commission
could work with the Department in the future to engage in a more substantive way
with these long-standing recommendations.
The oversight and monitoring of places of detention by independent bodies such
as the Australian Human Rights Commission plays an important role in shining a
light on conditions of detention in Australia. But merely shining a light is, on its own,
inadequate. It is what happens next that is the critical step.
It is my hope that this inspection report not only shines a light on the use of hotel
APODs in Australia, but leads to steps actually being taken to address the issues that
have been highlighted.
Lorraine Finlay
Human Rights Commissioner
June 2023
6