42
Maranga Mai!
White supremacy is the assumed superiority of whiteness, white culture, and white norms. It is an insidious
ideological, political and religious system maintaining institutional control. White supremacy manifests as
prejudice and bigotry in everyday life and is evident in extremist white supremacist violence like the March
2019 terrorist attack on masjidain in Christchurch. White supremacy assumes that non-white ways
of being are invalid and abnormal.
Denying racism
Historical amnesia
Avoiding the R-Word
Historical amnesia is an extension of the myth of
best race relations and whitewashes racism by
“misremembering” the past (Jackson, 2019, 2016).
Historical amnesia diminishes the violence and
racism of the past (MacDonald, 2018, p. v) through
deliberate forgetfulness and romanticisation of
healthy race relations:
New Zealand has an historical tendency to avoid
talking about racism deferring instead to euphemistic
discussions about unconscious bias and ‘casual
racism’ (Azarmandi, 2017). This avoids addressing
the impacts of racism, colonisation and white
supremacy in society today: “If we don’t talk about
racism then it follows that we cannot be racist”
(Cooper and Davis, 2013):
To ignore racism is to demonstrate an historical
amnesia, and a blindness to the ongoing legacies
of colonialism, the premise of which is white racial
superiority; that is, racism (Cooper, 2016).
The fallacy of the ‘best race relations’ in
the world
The myth that Aotearoa has had the ‘best race
relations’ in the world is another way of denying
racism (Sinclair, 1971). In the late nineteenth century,
for example, it was not uncommon to hear “never had
a civilised power treated a native race as kindly as
they had treated the Maori” (Wanganui Herald, 1894).
While this fiction has waned more recently (O’Malley,
2021), Pākehā once universally believed “no social
colour bar, no segregation in public transport or living
areas ever existed in New Zealand”. Without talking
to Māori, Pākehā believed there was “relatively little
social prejudice against Maoris” (Sinclair, 1971, p. 121).
The purpose of perpetuating an illusion of good race
relations is to whitewash systemic racism.
The myth of healthy race relations has obscured
the reality of what colonisation was and is. It has
replaced the harsh reality of its racist violence
and its illegitimate usurpation of power with a
feel good rhetoric of Treaty-based good faith and
Crown honour (Jackson, 2019).
In places like mid-twentieth century Taranaki, a colour
bar existed in all but name:
Māori were not welcome in any Pākehā social
institutions. Māori women were discouraged from
entering the only public restroom; the community
centre was regarded as a facility for Europeans
only (Ballara, 1986, pp. 61, 99).
In South Auckland between the 1920s and 1960s,
barbers refused to cut hair for Māori, theatres had
partitioned areas for Pākehā and Māori, by-laws
prevented landlords from renting a house to Māori,
schools had separate toilets for Māori students,
and Māori children swam in the afternoons so
they would not pollute the water before white
kids swam (Bartholomew in Te Karere, 2020;
Bartholomew, 2021, 2020).
Of course, there were exceptions, but this practice
was widespread in Aotearoa.