showed that they were not willing to see the issues as they are and address
them accordingly; rather, they saw it as an affront to their leadership and
management ability and sought to defend the actions of their staff or their
department. Frequently, they resort to repeating written policies, detailing
programmes, statistics, allocations, as their proof of the effectiveness of
their efforts and the good intention of the government.
However, it is evident from such replies that they are not aware of what
was actually happening on the ground, a result perhaps of fleeting working
visits or reliance on less than accurate reporting from their subordinates.
The stance taken by officers of the JHEOA whenever the interest of the
Orang Asli is juxtaposed against that of the state, can be best illustrated by
the following article from The Star of 22 March 1998:
The Star, 22 July 1998
A BURNING ISSUE
By Meng Yew Choong
WHILE plantations, which tend to be owned by large corporations,
could still get by (albeit at a cost) without using fire, the same
cannot be said of the tens of thousands of smallholders or
subsistence farmers. These people often do not have the
massive resources needed to practise zero-burning agricultural
techniques.
For these farmers, fire is a multipurpose tool, says Datuk Ahmad
Arshad, president of the National Association of Smallholders.
Fire eradicates pathogens and weeds that may reside in topsoil
and vegetation; it loosens soil and prepares it for planting almost
immediately -- doing the same with a tractor can cost up to RM250
a day, a sum beyond most smallholders’ means; fire also produces
fertiliser after the biomass is reduced to ash—a fertiliser that is
much cheaper than chemical ones.
ORANG ASLI – RIGHTS, PROBLEMS & SOLUTIONS
69