The government, however, continues to assert that only with resettlement
can Orang Asli be assured of proper health care and services. It refuses
to acknowledge that much of the lamentable health conditions in these
myriad schemes are due to the narrow subsistence base and psychological
disenfranchisement caused by uprooting Orang Asli from their traditional
territories.
Even more recently, in July 2004, when a study by UPM found high levels of
Escherichia coli in Tasik Chini lake that caused rashes and diarrhoea in some
Orang Asli living in their five lakeshore villages, the Minister in charge of
Orang Asli Affairs immediately suggested that the Orang Asli be resettled
into one place “so that they can attain proper amenities”. However, as the
village batin pointed out, the problem only started when the authorities
dammed the Chini River to prevent the lake water from flowing into the
Pahang River. Moreover, the university study plainly said the contamination
was due to improper sewage disposal by a local resort and by the Tasik Chini
national service camp at the lakeside! (The Star, 26 July 2004, 27 July 2004,
29 July 2004).
Such blame-shifting on health problems reveal the underclass status of
the Orang Asli. No dominant social group would accept such allegations
without a counter-challenge, and no politician would dare to pit himself
against a group that could jeopardise his own position. Such attitudes
about Orang Asli also clearly show how those responsible for promoting
Orang Asli welfare and health are themselves not informed or ignorant of
the issues involved. Worse, they wield their authority and dominance by
backing measures that would further marginalise the Orang Asli.
Insensitivity
The official stance of authority and dominance, coupled with ignorance of
Orang Asli culture, is sometimes reflected in an insensitive technocratic
way of handling problems. For example, in 1996, when the President of the
Malaysian Association of Maternal and Neonatal Health revealed that 60
ORANG ASLI – RIGHTS, PROBLEMS & SOLUTIONS
45