University Research Units
Centre for Applied Cross-Cultural Research,
Victoria University of Wellington
Multiculturalism: The cause of social problems or the cure for
social ills?
Diversity research
Overview
Aotearoa New Zealand continues to become more
culturally, ethnically, linguistically and religiously diverse.
Diversity research is required to ensure Aotearoa New
Zealand remains innovative and competitive on the global
stage, while safeguarding social cohesion and wellbeing
across our varied communities.
This year’s body of research relating to ethnic and cultural
diversity provides knowledge that can feed and inform
the work of policy and decision-makers at the highest
levels.
Diversity researchers face a number of challenges. These
include ensuring there is increased synergy between
researchers and stakeholders as well as addressing the
gaps in the production, distribution and application of
research by decision-makers. Sufficient funding also
continues to be a serious challenge, impacting on the
topics selected and the depth of research available.
For example, diversity is not recognised in the National
Science Challenges, despite being a fundamental area of
required focus for Aotearoa New Zealand over the next
20 years.
The following is a summary of some of the cultural
diversity research published in 2013. It was compiled by
Alicia Arnold, Centre for Applied Cross-Cultural Research,
Victoria University of Wellington. Emerging projects and
papers on cultural diversity in Aotearoa New Zealand can
be accessed on the CACR website: www.victoria.ac.nz/
cacr.
Contributed by Professor Colleen Ward, Centre for Applied
Cross-Cultural Research, Victoria University of Wellington.
This paper examines multiculturalism and its impact on the
psychological wellbeing of immigrant youth. Three aspects
of multiculturalism are investigated: cultural diversity in
the population; multicultural policy and the psychology of
everyday multiculturalism (positive and negative attitudes
toward immigrants). Alongside the negative effects of perceived
discrimination, the results showed that: 1) diversity per se was
associated with negative outcomes for immigrant youth (i.e.
predicted lower levels of self-esteem); 2) multicultural policies
were associated with positive outcomes (i.e. predicted higher
levels of self-esteem; and 3) widespread negative attitudes
towards immigrants were associated with negative outcomes (i.e.
predicted lower levels of life satisfaction). The research directly
addresses controversies about multiculturalism and has significant
policy implications for immigrant wellbeing.
Researchers: Prof. Colleen Ward and Dr Jaimee Stuart
Contact: jaimee.stuart@vuw.ac.nz and colleen.ward@vuw.ac.nz
Mapping the psychological state of the nation: A
barometer test of New Zealand’s multicultural status
This study looks at differences in the way ethnic groups view
ethnic equality, prejudice and intolerance; positive attitudes
toward diversity; patriotism and identity. It found that
expectations of race-based rejection were uncommon, intergroup
feelings were generally warm, perceived threat was moderately
low, expectations for future security were moderate and fairly
comparable across groups, and all groups expressed high levels of
patriotism. However, New Zealanders resisted a resource-specific
multicultural ideology that involves race-based interventions to
reduce social inequality. There was also evidence that the level
of warmth toward Asian New Zealanders was lower than that
toward other ethnic groups. The findings are discussed in relation
to socio-political issues, including tensions between biculturalism
and multiculturalism and the obstacles to reducing social
inequality across ethnic groups.
Published in the International Journal of Intercultural Relations,
37(6), 700-713.
Researchers: Dr Chris G. Sibley, Auckland University and Prof.
Colleen Ward, Centre for Applied Cross-cultural Research, Victoria
University of Wellington
Contact: c.sibley@auckland.ac.nz
Cultural intelligence predicts intercultural negotiation
effectiveness
This research project examines if cultural intelligence (CQ),
an ability to adapt and perform effectively in intercultural
situations, can predict effectiveness in intercultural negotiations.
The researchers paired negotiators from different cultures and
New Zealanders to examine the effect of CQ on intercultural
negotiations. Findings show that cultural intelligence predicts
intercultural negotiation effectiveness, while controlling for
cognitive ability, emotional intelligence, and personality.
Researchers found that overall CQ drove intercultural negotiation
outcomes rather than any one particular factor. The findings also
highlighted the importance of both migrants and existing New
Zealanders having high cultural intelligence.
Contact: Yee-Wei Ooi yee.ooi@vuw.ac.nz and Dr Ronald Fischer
ronald.fischer@vuw.ac.nz
60