Section 2: About the surveys
The 9–17 age group were targeted because
late childhood and early adolescence is a
common time for initial onset (or diagnosis) of
mental health conditions.7 Transitioning from
childhood into early adolescence includes the
onset of puberty combined with significant
social and environmental changes, such as the
move from primary school to high school, and
changes in family and community expectations
as a result of this transition. This can make
early adolescence a particularly stressful time.
While experiencing stress is normal, high levels
of stress can lead to mental health problems,
and existing mental health problems can
heighten negative responses to stress.8 Given
that early adolescence is already known to be a
critical juncture, it is important that the added
complexity of the pandemic is explored for this
age group.
2.3 Methodology
The project involved a mixed methods
approach. This included surveys with children,
parents/guardians and grandparents to
understand their experiences, as well
as consultations with a small number of
stakeholders who were involved in the delivery
of mental health services for children. These
stakeholder consultations helped to inform the
design of the surveys. Roundtables were also
conducted following an initial analysis of the
survey responses, providing an opportunity to
gain additional insights from key experts.
(a) Human rights-based approach
A human rights-based approach guided all
aspects of this project. The most common
description of a human rights-based approach is
the PANEL framework:9
20 |
These principles guided the survey design and
distribution process, including the information
provided to participants, and the approach to
analysis and report writing.
(b) Literature review
The design of the surveys was informed by a
literature review, which included a review of
the existing literature on child mental health
and wellbeing in Australia, both pre-pandemic
and contemporary, and the systems and
conditions that support positive mental health
and wellbeing. It also included a review of
relevant government policies to understand the
government decisions about pandemic-related
restrictions.
The review primarily considered literature
published over the past 10 years. However,
given the emergent nature of evidence around
the impact of the pandemic on children’s mental
health and wellbeing, other sources, such as
reports from key non-government organisations
and some media reports quoting recognised
experts about the potential impacts, are also
referenced.
The literature review is located in Appendix
1 and is referred to where relevant specific
findings have been cited in the body of this
report.
Additional literature was also identified after
the initial review was completed, and is included
throughout the report to support findings.
(c) Stakeholder interviews
Stakeholder interviews were held with
representatives from seven key mental health
services that provide mental health support
for children. The services were located across
Australia, but were predominantly in New South
Wales (NSW), Victoria, and South Australia.
The primary purpose of the stakeholder
interviews was to inform the design of the
surveys and ensure they included questions
about the mental health and wellbeing issues
commonly raised with key service providers by
children during the pandemic.
The interviews occurred during October and
November 2021 via video conferencing and
were up to one hour in length. Interviewees
were asked for their observations on children’s
mental health during the pandemic, and
about how they adapted their practice to
assist children, and parents/guardians and
grandparents during this time.
(d) Survey design
Two online surveys were developed—one
targeted at children aged 9–17 years, and
the other targeted at parents/guardians and
grandparents. The surveys were programmed
using Qualtrics and housed on the Australian
Human Rights Commission’s (AHRC) website.
The children’s survey included 34 questions
consisting of a mixture of Likert scales,
dichotomous questions, checklists, and free-text
items.
The survey for parents/guardians and
grandparents was designed to complement
the children’s survey. Parents/guardians and
grandparents were invited to participate if they
had a child in their family aged 9–17. The survey
included questions about their own experiences,
and those of their child. After answering
questions about their own experiences and
feelings, parents/guardians and grandparents
were provided with the option to complete a
survey on behalf of their child aged 9–17 about
their experiences or they could nominate for
their child to complete their own survey about
their experiences. Around a third of the parents/
guardians and grandparents group opted to
complete the children’s survey questions on
behalf of their child.
‘Mental health shapes my life’: COVID-19 & kids’ wellbeing • 2022 | 21